News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by ctide on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:34PM (#3187945)
Have you used the Google Voice app for the iPhone? It's literally the worst app I've ever seen in my life. Crashed constantly, won't refresh from the server, will close your text box randomly while typing a message (clearing your message), will fail to make calls frequently, and since I upgraded to iOS5 now has signed me out and crashes immediately when trying to sign back in so it's been rendered completely unusable.

I can only assume that there's some desire within Google to make sure the iPhone versions of their products are complete dogshit to try and encourage Android adoption.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by jad on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:43PM (#3188300)
> I can only assume that there's some desire within Google to make sure the iPhone versions of their products are complete dogshit to try and encourage Android adoption.

Do people think companies really behave this way? "Hey guys, how can we make our products crappier? Surely if people think our iPhone apps stink, they'll be motivated to go out and buy a whole phone from us!"

There are a whole host of mundane reasons why products turn out worse than they could be, and they almost never include conspiracy or malice.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by ry0ohki on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @05:01PM (#3188915)
I bet it's the same reason Apple products suck on Windows... the devs themselves just don't use the platform.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by jad on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:13PM (#3189363)
Actually, from what I understand, Apple products are used quite extensively by Google employees. I have friends who work there, and there are lots of developers there who use Macs for day-to-day work. My understanding is that the Google Voice iOS app began life as a Google employee's side project, scratching his own itch. I've heard that even relatively senior managers use iPhones as their cell phone. This speaks favorably of Google's corporate culture, in my opinion.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by omaranto on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @06:15PM (#3189193)
Well, I'm not convinced it's fair to say that Apple software is worse on Windows. I don't know anyone who's tried Safari on Windows (so maybe it is worse than on a Mac, but I wouldn't know) and while iTunes is certainly absolutely terrible on Windows, from what my Mac owning friends tell me it is just as bad on Macs.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by shinratdr on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:35PM (#3189791)
> from what my Mac owning friends tell me it is just as bad on Macs.

Who told you that? I just launched iTunes on my Lion machine, it started up in 5 seconds and started syncing with my phone wirelessly while I scrolled through 18,000 tracks without stuttering & a track played.

iTunes for OS X is arguably a little bloated and lacking direction, but it's still hands down the best library based music player/jukebox for OS X. Nothing else even comes close.

To be fair, you come right out and say you have little experience on the topic either way, so why cast an opinion? As someone who uses Apple's software on Macs and PCs extensively, there is not even a debate to be had about where Apple puts its effort.

You can even test it yourself. Take any Mac, put Windows 7 on it. Launch a clean copy of iTunes in OS X, then reboot and do the same in Windows 7. The OS X version will start up instantly, the Windows one will stall for at least 10-15 seconds. This is just one obvious example, there are plenty more out there.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by omaranto on Thursday November 03, 2011 @09:01AM (#3191496)
You're right that I shouldn't have offered a second-hand (my friends') opinion about iTunes and specially not without spelling it out. What happened was that I complained about iTunes on Windows (which I use to put stuff on my iPod Touch), specifically that (1) it sometimes incorrectly marked podcasts as played or as not played, (2) it sometimes hung trying to connect to the iTunes store (for Windows users: if this happens run ipconfig /flushdns in a cmd window and restart iTunes), (3) somethings where hard to find in the UI (I can't remeber my concrete example now, but I did mention it when I complained with my friends), (4) rearranging app icons on the iPod's homescreen is quite buggy: you often windup with empty spots or duplicated icons in iTunes, which then crashes if you try to sync. (I did not complain about startup time, since it doesn't really bother me; and I should also say recent versions of iTunes on Windows don't have some of these problems) My friends said that all of my complaints save for (2) also happened on Macs.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by sjwright on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:03PM (#3189667)
> Do people think companies really behave this way?

An interesting anecdote from the Steve Jobs biography:

Finding Nemo had just been released to critical acclaim and Pixar were in renegotiation talks about their deal with Disney.

(Disney's) Michael Eisner had one powerful trump card. Even if Pixar didn't renew, Disney had the right to make sequels of Toy Story and the other movies Pixar had made, and it owned all the characters from Woody to Nemo. Eisner was already planning -- or threatening -- to have Disney's own animation studio do a Toy Story 3, which Pixar had declined to do.

The threat had teeth not because Pixar would lose control of some of their characters, but because Disney's animation studio had been releasing flop after flop. After ten years of The Lion King, Beauty and the Beast, and Aladdin, there were ten years of rubbish. As a company, Disney had been creatively brain-dead for a decade.

(Pixar's) John Lasseter was aghast at the prospect of breaking up with Disney. "I was worried about my children, what they would do with the characters we'd created," he recalled. "It's like you have these dear children and you have to give them up to be adopted by convicted child molesters."

Effectively, Disney's negotiation tactic was "re-sign with us, or else we'll spin up a shitty division to make shitty sequels of your movies!"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circle_7_Animation

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toy_Story_3#Production

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by nl on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:25PM (#3189747)
Effectively, Disney's negotiation tactic was "re-sign with us, or else we'll spin up a shitty division to make shitty sequels of your movies!"

That's from Pixar's perspective.

From Disney, it was more like this: "re-sign with us or we will utilise out right to produce sequels, for which you won't be paid"

ie, It wasn't a threat to do a bad job - as the parent comment says, companies (almost never) deliberately do bad work.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by sjwright on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:15AM (#3195145)
Deciding to do work within a limited budget is tantamount to deliberately doing bad work in many instances. For example, look at Disney's history with direct-to-video sequels -- they exist purely to make money, and contain little of the magic or refinement of their fully budgeted forebears.

Eisner might not have been thinking 'shitty', but I bet he was thinking similar things when approving The Return of Jafar. (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0107952/)

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by sjwright on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:19AM (#3195152)
Furthermore look at the promotional poster for Toy Story 3. It's quite clearly a slap-dash effort made by a third rate hack. I mean, who recalls a product and leaves it on the store shelf, with a strategically placed sticker that could well be saying "NEW!"?

That poster could only have been made to intimidate Pixar.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by TheFuture on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:06PM (#3189336)
No, you don't say "lets make crap". But you deny the proper resources. You place unnecessary restrictions on the project. You hire a bunch of iOS newbies and say "hey go make gmail, but you have to make it out of javascript in a UIwebview" and basically force the outcome.

Come on, hasn't everyone had to work on a project where the boss/manager didn't want it to succeed? Whether for political, personal, or boredom, people don't do their best work all the time. Not everyone is as demanding as Steve Jobs.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by Splines on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @03:29PM (#3188537)
I think it's probably more that the Android apps team has a higher budget/headcount than the iPhone apps team (I have no idea, but just a guess).
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by sunchild on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:55PM (#3188362)
More like "Hey guys, how can we make sure our products run better on our platform than the other one?
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by pflats on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @03:12PM (#3188440)
>I can only assume that there's some desire within Google to make sure the iPhone versions of their products are complete dogshit to try and encourage Android adoption.

I find it interesting that Google is intentionally using its own icons for pre-existing iOS conventions (Floppy disk for save, weird action menu, nonstandard trash can, buttons without borders, etc.) I can understand being in love with your own system, but making a native app look non-native is just odd.

Personally, Google Sync/Exchange works great, gives me calendars as well, and plays nicely with my other accounts. The only hiccup is archive v. delete, but that's not a huge one. I've had no desire for a GMail app.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by MaysonL on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @04:12PM (#3188718)
The weirdest Google-ism I found was when running the desktop version of Reader on my iPad: single-finger scrolling was turned off! I had to use two fingers as if I was using a Mac trackpad.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by rboyce on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @06:13PM (#3189185)
That's actually a consequence of how iOS handled scrollable areas on pages prior to iOS 5. Totally not Google's fault; I believe you'll have better luck using desktop Reader in iOS 5.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by avree on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:36PM (#3187949)
Did you update the Google Voice app? These all used to be problems, but their latest release resolved them all for me.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by moxiemk1 on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:59PM (#3188080)
This is true - the Google Voice app is now much much better, but it is worth pointing out that there were tons of bugs that weren't fixed for over a year, like:

* freezing irrecoverably when opening the app/going to inbox very often

* losing all the text you've typed when anything causes the textfield to lose focus

* things like gaining network connectivity causing said textfield to lose focus

Perhaps this qualifies as ad hominem, but this experience was biblically awful and from a major software company. Seeing how this new Gmail app is a bunch of Web views and needlessly non-standard widgets (=> part of the worst dredge of apps), it makes me start to feel pretty cynical about their iOS strategy.

Then again, taken the experience using the Android browser while developing mobile websites, maybe it's an institutional inability to develop polished mobile applications.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by ctide on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:39PM (#3187967)
No, I switched to one of the paid apps (GV Mobile+) because it actually worked.

EDIT: I don't really know why I'm being downvoted for this. Wouldn't you switch apps too if you relied on google voice for your text messages and you couldn't log into it anymore without it instantly crashing?

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by chaz on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:50PM (#3188027)
Hanlon's Razor. There was a login bug with iOS 5, and Google pulled the iPhone app from the Appstore until it was fixed. It's been back for a little while now, and stable.

The Android version is far better, though, due to its OS integration. I don't think Apple would ever allow what it does on Android.

Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by avree on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:10PM (#3188128)
The only way to get that integration is to either use Sprint or jailbreak and use http://gvexts.appspot.com/sms/sms.html
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by ctide on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:54PM (#3188048)
Yes, I don't doubt that the iOS5 login bug was not intentional, however every other issue I mentioned has been there since I switched back to an iPhone from Droid when the Verizon iPhone was released. That's nearly a year of a completely malfunctioning app (although, I could actually log in to that one.)
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by falling on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:02PM (#3188093)
They've had the iOS 5 beta available since June and they didn't bother to fix it before the actual release. If that doesn't say that they don't care, I don't know what else.
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by X-Istence on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:53PM (#3188040)
Google has actually fixed these issues. The Google Voice app now works perfectly fine on my iPhone 4S...
Re:Introducing the Gmail app for iPhone, iPad and iPod touch by mikeash on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:49PM (#3188336)
Why put any effort into making a deliberately bad app when they could even more easily make no app at all?