News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:College has been oversold by edderly on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:39PM (#3187966)
I agree and disagree. If you take a historical perspective of the role of universities with respect to corporate employment a university education was just needed to validate whether someone was of 'high calibre'.

In the past anecdotally at least in the City of London 'well rounded' individuals were preferred for high finance i.e. you might be better off studying Classics at Oxbridge than pure math. Today this is probably less true as computerization and trading systems have come to the fore.

However, I would be very surprised that in your case you didn't have all of those skills mentioned in place before going to university. Is it likely they got some enhancement? It certainly wouldn't do any harm studying anything in a good department.

I don't see any tangible evidence that 'soft skills' are manufactured out of liberal studies and I find it a baffling conclusion that there even would be an automatic superiority of these skills versus a 'high calibre' person studying engineering.

[deleted]
Re:College has been oversold by edderly on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:03PM (#3188099)
I don't think I'm twisting the argument. You said that you believe you gathered these skills as a result of your curriculum choice.

Although I think plenty of other comments defending Liberal Arts make this point more explicitly about the relative benefits.

Re:College has been oversold by mattmcknight on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @12:58PM (#3187744)
"But what I learned in those courses, being inspired by amazing faculty was more on the soft skills side: Self-confidence, critical reading, critical writing, argumentation, strong communication skills, problem-solving, strong analytical research abilities, ability to lead groups etc etc..."

But couldn't you have learned those skills with another degree as well? So, wouldn't you have been better off learning those skills in classes where you also learned about the subject matter in the area where you are working?

[deleted]
Re:College has been oversold by Fliko on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:25PM (#3187889)
You get the same interactions and knowledge with any degree at a decent enough school. Your promotions don't speak so much about your education but more so about you as a person.
Re:College has been oversold by philwelch on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @01:25PM (#3187891)
Case in point, Andrew Mason, CEO of Groupon, what did he study? Oh yeah, he studied Music at Northwestern...

I'm curious: where did Mr. Ponzi get his degree?

Yes, it's pretty obvious that if you get into a name-brand university and manage to teach yourself marketable skills on the side, you can be pretty successful. What if you don't get into a name-brand university? You're screwed for life and your best shot at success is to work for someone like you? No thanks.

[deleted]
Re:College has been oversold by philwelch on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:01PM (#3188088)
No, I meant the actual Mr. Ponzi: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Ponzi

It was a rhetorical question. The point was, Andrew Mason's accomplishments don't seem quite so respectable anymore.

The article is about the growing number of Liberal Arts graduate s. My point is that if you are going to study liberal arts in this economy, you'd be better off studying somewhere good and have more opportunities later.

I submit that if you get into a name brand university, you probably already have the upper-middle-class/upper-class background, connections, and upbringing necessary to do well in the job market regardless of what you actually study. And either way, now that you're in the elite social category of "people who got into a name brand university". That's all status, and no one ever argued that status didn't get you places in the world.

Re:College has been oversold by juiceandjuice on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:56PM (#3188371)
Andrew Mason also interned at Electrical Audio Studios.
Re:College has been oversold by Eeko on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @12:58PM (#3187738)
Where are your classmates of Dev. Studies and Philosophy right now? They all did CSE in their spare time?