News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Papers on GitHub Copilot, copyright law, and ownership fo... by ghaff on Saturday June 25, 2022 @09:39AM (#31875215)
>Open source or proprietary you still have to respect the license.

>they might claim that I did not learned from their code but memorize secret algorithms

The difference is that you can't claim open source code is a trade secret that contains algorithms that you can't reimplement in your own code.

Re:Papers on GitHub Copilot, copyright law, and ownership fo... by simion314 on Saturday June 25, 2022 @10:48AM (#31875736)
>The difference is that you can't claim open source code is a trade secret that contains algorithms that you can't reimplement in your own code.

You can't use "trade secret" but MS Windows code is also no longer secret, they shared the code with third parties and was also leaked, so they can claim you do not respect the license or TOS,NDAs etc. Not sure if "secret" has anything to do with this, proprietary stuff is not secret, it could be source availleble or be a scripting language stuff or something trivial to find the original implementation like C# and Java

Re:Papers on GitHub Copilot, copyright law, and ownership fo... by tuckerman on Saturday June 25, 2022 @11:53AM (#31876234)
It’s possible for there to be patent encumbered algorithms in open source code though. A license like Apache will contain a free license to use them to use/distribute the open source work… which I’m not sure would transfer if copilot happens to plop some unlicensed, unattributed violating code in your code base.
Re:Papers on GitHub Copilot, copyright law, and ownership fo... by ghaff on Saturday June 25, 2022 @12:13PM (#31876428)
At least some lawyers [1] will argue that code under an open source license like MIT has an implicit patent grant even absent specific verbiage.

[1] https://opensource.com/article/18/3/patent-grant-mit-license

Re:Papers on GitHub Copilot, copyright law, and ownership fo... by tuckerman on Saturday June 25, 2022 @01:46PM (#31877202)
It would be interesting to see if this sort of implicit grant, or even the explicit ones, extend to using the patent outside the context of the original work.

My main concern here is that copilot itself might not be illegal but that it is causing otherwise well-meaning developers to put themselves at legal risk.