Re:US Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade [pdf]
by pyronik19 on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:30PM
(#31865067)
Common Law interpretation sure, you need to use the logic and decisions of the court to inform future decisions, but those decisions must be grounded on actual text and insofar as bad decisions are made they should be corrected. Should we have left all of the bad decisions on slavery and Jim Crow because of stare decisis?
Re:US Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade [pdf]
by maratc on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:03PM
(#31865734)
> those decisions must be grounded on actual text
Uhm, no — “precedent” is a judicial decision which may not be grounded on any text whatsoever. It’s a common thing in Common law, and of course it doesn’t exist in Continental law.
Re:US Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade [pdf]
by pyronik19 on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:53PM
(#31866578)
which may not be grounded on any text whatsoever.
Well when your job is to interpret the constitution, it should be grounded on the text. That's why there are textualist who disagree with your interpretation of the role of the court. It is supposed to be the foundation.
The Continental law is based on another philosophy — you have no rights except the ones that are explicitly given to you by law, and the only way to have more rights passes through the legislature. There are many countries that employ Continental law, but the US is not one of them.