Sounds like you are buying a transferable licence?
(If this isn't a licence, what would you call it? As presumably once you have 'sold' it, it can still reside on your laptop but you aren't allowed to play it).
It's not a license because it cannot be revoked by whoever sold it to you.
So once I sell it, if it's still on my hard-drive am I allowed to listen to it in your world?
And if I have it but am not allowed to listen to it, what is that lack of playing-permission called if not 'not owning a license'?
> It's not a license because it cannot be revoked by whoever sold it to you.
Licences can be irrevocable, so this isn't a necessary property of a licence.
I don't recall the precise case law that applies to CDs. There's certainly a version of things (probably the one desired by record companies) in which one or both of these is true (a) you can't rip it (b) you can't listen to the rips after you've sold it.
Remember, methods of enforcing such a legal regime are distinct from the regime itself.
> Licences can be irrevocable, so this isn't a necessary property of a licence.
With networked digital technology, it is not always a matter of the legal terms of the license. If the playback mechanism requires contacting a remote server, whether you have a license of not does not matter if said server is no longer in existence.
And sure, licenses can be irrevocable, but those connected with digital media, in general, have not been.
Where x describes a licence, just with different licensing terms.
The same is possible with physical media. Analog media can be duplicated with varying levels of loss, digital media can be duplicated with no loss, and then the original item resold. Why must digital files be treated significantly differently, and suddenly DRM is required to even allow legitimate resale?
If copyright owners had their way, they’d automatically get a blanket license to everyone’s content, while giving the individual person zero rights. The historical behavior of the industry (all the way back to Thomas Edison) indicates that this would be the case.
What would be wrong with the same first sale doctrine that applies to physical instances of digital media (such as CDs) ?
CD: You buy it, you are free to resell it to someone else; you are not free to make copies.
Digital data only: You buy it, you can resell it someone else (0); you are not free give additional copies to anyone else (1)
(0) not likely to happen (1) you can of course make your own copies, eg. for backup or across devices
Would enforcing such a legal structure be possible? Yes and no. Everyone knows that once you could rip CDs, the legal structure for that format was already severely challenged by people's actual behavior, so there's nothing particularly new there.