Re:Copilot sells code other people wrote
by Guid_NewGuid on Thursday June 23, 2022 @01:59PM
(#31852834)
Don't get me wrong, I know this (copyright abolition) is pie-in-the-sky stuff. I'm using an anon account to post because even advocating for it could be troublesome for employment. But I don't accept we have to be meek or have small goals in talking about this ideological stuff. And I think this has made me realise why I find the Free Software vision so disappointing and weak. And hence why I find all these (ideologically) Free Software aligned takes of sending Billy to jail for a thousand years so irritating.
If an AI takes a copyright work and makes its own version-- say combining two novels by popular authors in a way that is unique but keeps large parts of the text intact, can I sell that? I think if I were the authors I would be unhappy.
Also, how hard would it be for copilot to include a comment saying "// I got this line from x repo" when you are copying from a new repo? I am guessing not hard at all. Then at least the user would be aware of where their code was coming from and could be expected to make a judgement. If the line is "let a = b" then probably no worries. But if it is hundreds of lines of a simulation, all from the same repo with no changes, then I think some attribution is good for both parties.