News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Khan Academy: Computer Science by rudiger on Tuesday November 01, 2011 @06:55PM (#3184539)
SICP doesn't introduce assignment until two hundred pages in.
Re:Khan Academy: Computer Science by tikhonj on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @02:28AM (#3185657)
And, if I remember correctly, it never introduces loops.

On the other hand, you learn about laziness, higher-order functions, deterministic and logic programming and how to implement the aforementioned, on top of a bunch of stuff you would learn in a Java class like recursion, OOP and networking. All this in the first four chapters; the fifth one introduces a low-level register based language but my class never got to it :( It is pretty cool.

Ultimately, SICP just has drastically different (and I think better) priorities and topics than any course taught in Java or Python. I also suspect that a good SICP course moves even faster than the material here, simply because of the sheer density of big ideas in the book and the simplicity of Scheme.

Re:Khan Academy: Computer Science by tel on Tuesday November 01, 2011 @08:10PM (#3184758)
Assignment isn't idiomatic in functional programming.
Re:Khan Academy: Computer Science by dpritchett on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @11:16AM (#3187143)
The functional programming is a side effect of the desire to teach computer science in a low-friction way. It's nice to not have to also teach Java along with your CS concepts.

I know that when I teach myself anything it's best to focus on one new concept at a time. Scheme's light weight allows all but the CS concepts to fall away from the new coder's consideration.

Re:Khan Academy: Computer Science by tel on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @11:50AM (#3187331)
The functional programming is a side effect of the desire to teach computer science in a low-friction way.

And why not code in a low-friction way even when not being taught? I wasn't intending to defend FP, but I think it's silly to think of assignment as a fundamental part of CS or the art of coding. It's just one tool.