Our interpretation of sensory experience is a large part of what our "self" is
Considering that our conscious experience is the experience of processing information, when we lack sensory input shit kinda gets wild (technical terms only here)
Sensory processing is happening literally constantly and its essentially inseparable from our every day experience. Because it is our everyday experience
The way we interact is important, back to the simulation question if the inputs and outputs can be sufficiently matched to how real molecules interact with out receptor proteins we can absolutely blur that line between digital and physical even more
It is something like how quantum effects work when we measure them. A conscious capable entity has the closed loop needed to have the capacity to [something] "self."
(Yeah, there is a word missing and it is missing because I lack understanding.)
Sensory deprivation seems to really impact us as well! Maybe that closed loop is always needed, like oxygen is for our bodies. We may endure a brief excursion "all inside the box", but a longer time leads to madness, damage.
However it works, the fact is we have a robust and high fidelity perception of ourselves and the world and we feed on all like food and water. It is very suggestive, and I find thoughts along these lines compelling and difficult to reason about. We are missing something basic. Of that I am sure.