IMHO, the law usually exists for a reason. I care about antitrust violations, or data privacy violations. If New York requires hotels to be licensed - which I think is a fair requirement - then I don't see why Airbnb patrons should be exempt from that law. This view will probably be unpopular on HN.
I don't suggest that the US government stop "harassing" startups because ... they're startups, and economy economy economy.
I think you need to find a way to spur wealth creation while still having some rule of law in the country. Tax breaks, government-sponsored venture capital, and immigration incentives are a great way to do that.
I think there is validity to the idea that venues that provide accommodation should be licensed and certified by the government to ensure quality, safety, and accessibility standards. Do you disagree?
Quality: Zagat's star ratings are superior to anything a .gov agency has produced.
Safety: Chicago Crime Maps is superior to anything the Chicago PD has produced. Among other things, a mild tweak can accomodate self reports rather than just things that the police got around to filing (police officers have a number of incentives to understate crime).
Accessibility: Google Maps ftw. Will tell you if accessible by car, train, foot, bike.
Government agencies can't go out of business (no downside) and have zero incentive to do an amazing job (no upside). It is no surprise that this produces DMV/TSA style mediocrity.
Quality: I'm not talking about star ratings. I'm talking about ensuring hygiene and safety (see below).
Safety: I was referring to the need for an authority to ensure that the building is safe for use as accommodation. Are its stairs adequate? Is the wood stable? Are the windows high enough? Is its balcony safe? (for children?) Are there any open boilers or pipes? Is there proper air ventilation? Are there mats in its bathrooms?
These are all questions that pertain to the safety of people staying at the venue. It doesn't matter that you or someone else might be willing to take the risk to save a couple of dollars. That's not how the law works.
Accessibility: accommodation venues should provide facilities for disabled persons as is required by the law. The fact that you run your business on Airbnb should not exclude you from those requirements.
>Government agencies can't go out of business (no downside) and have zero incentive to do an amazing job (no upside). It is no surprise that this produces DMV/TSA style mediocrity.
Yep, I'm not going to start an argument about the merits of the government as a concept. I would, however, ask you to compare the state of countries that have a functioning, democratic government, and the countries that don't.
Napster and Youtube broke copyright laws. So did Google. Apple's Jobs was a phone phreak. Gates was disciplined by the Ad Board for selling software on campus. And Facebook's creator famously "breach[ed] security, violating copyrights and violating individual privacy by creating the website, www.facemash.com".
Good entrepreneurs don't give a damn about "the rules", or about those whose primary purpose in life is obeying rules or making up new ones. Indeed, good entrepreneurs have a healthy disrespect for the law. But unlike the common criminal, they break the law to create rather than to destroy.
Your assumption is that the legal system is on the side of the average Joe and is protecting their interests against "for profit companies". It is much more accurate to say that a law is like a stationary cannon, which is captured by those with the deepest pockets and aimed at those who would pose market threats to those deep pockets.
Real estate developers who already own property support restrictive zoning laws to keep rents high. Life insurers are the biggest lobbyists for the death tax. Large restaurant chains support food safety inspection regimes that result in reams of paperwork, as they can amortize this cost across more employees.
Stated good intentions mean nothing. Every system of laws will face gaming attempts from day one, not just from "evil for profit startups" but also from corrupt politicians, bureaucrats, and lobbyists.
This needs to be factored into your analysis, as you too easily accept the narrative of "data privacy law" rather than "a law passed to advance the career of so-and-so politician and NGO, funded by lobbyist X, covered sympathetically by journalist Y, and sold to us as a data privacy law".
Every law? Antitrust laws? Data privacy laws? Laws that require hotels to be licensed?
If you take issue with a law, then that law is the problem; not the enforcing of it.
Startups should not be exempt from the law simply because they're a startup. There are better ways to spur wealth creation via small businesses than to allow small businesses to flaunt the law when they see fit.
How did all the microsoft antitrust stuff help us? How is hassling google helping us?
I think we're in agreement with respect to the law, the point of the parent post was that instead of hair-brained schemes to increase the number of startups we should reduce useless laws and regulations so that they can thrive.
Can you really justify that statement?
If you're regularly breaking laws in business, it's probably not a tech company. It's probably a restaurant, health services or construction company, where there are immense networks of regulation at every level.
Generally, though, you're going to be SOL on government regulation as technology's main problem. There really isn't much, especially vis-a-vis more lucrative industries like oil. Wal-Mart probably has more regulatory compliance issues than the entire tech world.
The root of this problem lies in the inevitable merger of the corporate and political classes. As the lines between these two entities blur, disruption through innovation will increasingly be hindered by new legislation. Corporations and governments are both interested in one thing: maintaining power. Corporations through monopoly, and governments through engineering votes.
Until this unholy alliance is broken, innovation will only become more cumbersome.
I agree that some of the problem is the government being a "trust buster" - however, some of it is simply the faultless way the market works. The government makes blanket anti-trust policies which are universal enough that, when one company revolutionizes an industry to the point that it's the only one of its kind, it's caught by policy without really having any bad intentions. Unfortunately this is happening to Google.
Google does not have a monopoly on search. It's just the dominant player. That said, I do think there's reason for concern about how Google is marketing and integrating their products.
What would be concerning if Google started making it harder for other search engines to come along and challenge its position by offering a better service. Google has done no such thing. It's as easy to challenge Google as it ever was.
What's of concern to me and the US policy makers is how Google is using its position as the dominant search engine to market its other products. Do you see the difference?
Are all those bundling moves are best for the consumer ? maybe not.
Is google buying ITA - the flight comparison service gives value to people, instead of google recommending you a great flight search when you search for a flight , and letting providers compete among themselves ? or even showing data from flight search providers directly on the page? i'm not sure it's helpful for the consumer, and it would probably decrease competition in the flight comparison services, or maybe even kill the competition totally.
Is it a legal monopoly, and break anti-trust laws ? i dunno. But don't mistake the law with the reality.
However, if the goal is to have more startups that are "the envy of the world", then increasing the number is not necessarily the way to do this.
We need to stop harassing those startups that do become successful. Startups by their nature are disruptive in the common sense of the term, and will violate the cozy arrangements made between established businesses and governments.
Two recent examples:
http://www.betabeat.com/2011/05/31/airbnb-takes-manhattan-wi...
http://venturebeat.com/2010/10/26/ubercab-ryan-graves-cease-...
Of course, on a larger scale the government is now harassing Google with antitrust, even though Google is being nipped at the heels by Facebook.
The government also denied the Blockbuster/Hollywood merger in the mid 2000s (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A2310-2005Mar2...) on antitrust grounds. Of course, just a few years later these "trusts" were blown up by Netflix, which is itself being blown up by Amazon and iTunes.
To have more successes, we need to stop the dynamic in which government goes after successes and tries to destroy them. What we don't need are government policies that encourage more marginal entrepreneurs to jump into the pool.