Re:Ask HN: Feel bad about working in crypto, what to do?
by jagtesh on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @06:29AM
(#31822327)
You’re on point except for one big difference: a block chain is distributed.
I don’t think it is foolproof, as no tech really is. But the concept seems to significantly raise the cost and complexity of an attack to compromise it.
The simplest way I can imagine doing it is - spoofing network requests from the party trying to verify something, or routing that request to a compromised node. I will make a guess that networking equipment in a govt. setting can protect against a low level attack.
Disclaimer: I take a passive interest in this space but have never studied or implemented a block-chain application.
Re:Ask HN: Feel bad about working in crypto, what to do?
by giaour on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:51AM
(#31835964)
In practice, blockchains tend to be extremely centralized without a deliberate effort to prevent them from becoming so. (Cf https://www.nber.org/papers/w29396) You can get around this in a permissioned blockchain with a minimum quorum size, but at that point, you're basically running a fancy git repository with a number of mirrors.
During my time in government, shady contractors pitching blockchain to solve literally every problem was so common and so preposterous that it quickly became a meme. "Immuatble public records" was a common claim, but "blockchain" isn't fundamentally different from a git repository in this regard.
If all you need is a replicated merkle tree, we have easier and more efficient ways of doing that.