Why do you think the majority of people don't care how a computer works? Simply because they don't want to learn, and they think mostly in the short term. (Not that I'd blame them. Short term thinking tends to be emphasised by our current western society.)
Of course you can't apply FOSS principle everywhere. Buildings and cars are scarce. You can't copy them the way you copy software.
You also assume that the market is efficient. It isn't. Even when doing the most ridiculous assumptions about human nature (homo economicus), the market simply isn't efficient. Therefore, the most popular product cannot be assumed to be the best, or even have the best cost/benefit ratio. And you know about Microsoft's OEM scheme. That gives them an advantage that has nothing to do with the quality of their software.
You also seem to assume FOSS doesn't have such a great market share. On the desktop, sure. But on the server, it won.
I'm neither defending nor vilifying corporations or other secrets-holders. But secrets are a big piece of the semi-functional market system that allows software engineers to draw a paycheck. If you want to talk about subverting or supplanting that market system, I'm ecstatic to have that conversation. But advocating FOSS without addressing the economic issues is pure dreaming. (Not that I'm knocking dreaming; but it's only useful as Step #0).
> advocating FOSS without addressing the economic issues is pure dreaming.
Totally agree. Now I discovered today that Stallman is probably aware of the economic issues[1]. Still, he doesn't deal with them. I don't know why, but I guess he may estimate there are other competent people working on just that (he repeatedly said that Free Software is a cause besides many others, and that he chose this one because he could).
[1] http://www.harishanker.net/2009/06/richard-stallman-intervie... It's not fleshed out, but I take it as evidence that Stallman at least thought about it.
It's simple: information asymmetry can be very, very profitable. Why should Coca-Cola have the right to keep their formula secret, even though I pay for their product? Because they risk losing money if someone could clone the recipe (you could patent it, but that arguably creates less freedom, not more). Other examples abound. And just because it's possible to make money using "open information" business models doesn't mean you can make the same scale of revenue, or apply a successful model to any particular industry. (Good engineers are expensive.)
I'm completely in favor of all software being open. For that matter, I'm also in favor of a socialist paradise where every human has food, shelter, education and health care. But you can't just wave a wand or declare a mandate; we need new socioeconomic structures, whether by design or through natural emergence. But moral condemnations make very little progress, and as a FOSS spokesman and advocate, that is all Stallman has to offer.