News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by funkah on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:17PM (#3178857)
Kottke called Stallman's rider (the whole thing) "crazy and amazing". Then he quoted the parrot thing, probably because it tickled his fancy. I don't agree that that constitutes "ridicule", in Winer's words.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by gojomo on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:38PM (#3178928)
Indeed – Kottke didn't indicate shunning-disapproval or even necessarily 'ridicule' (as both Winer and others downthread summarize Kottke).

Kottke's chosen words aren't always meant negatively. ("Here's to the crazy ones...")

In Kottke's context, he's given a fair description: the rider is, objectively, quite peculiar and illuminating about Stallman's intense priorities. But whether a reader takes that as a reason to shun and ostracize Stallman, as with disrespectful 'ridicule', is up to the reader.

Do we think Kottke would counsel Stallman, if we were in some bizarro universe where Stallman sought others' advice, not to include those two paragraphs, because they're too ridiculous?

I think it's equally likely Kottke would chuckle and say, "the bit about the parrots is crazy and brilliant, better even than the Van Halen thing... move it up higher!"

Read Stallman charitably. Read Kottke charitably. Read everyone charitably.

Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by nmcfarl on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:12PM (#3179093)
> Read Stallman charitably. Read Kottke charitably. Read everyone charitably

This!

Always, every day. You might make the world a little bit better in the process, but you will make your life a good bit less stressful, just by being a bit more charitable, a bit less suspicious.

Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by Fliko on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:02PM (#3179051)
I was disappointed in Kottke with the fact that he didn't know why Van Halen had requested brown free bowl of M&Ms in his contract. (It was so he would know if the stage crew read the contract which contained safety info on their equipment, to help ensure that no one was harmed during the show, as they had some of the most complicated and dangerous stage equipment at the time)
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by ngkabra on Monday October 31, 2011 @06:40PM (#3179474)
It is very likely that Kottke does know about the reasons behind Van Halen's free bowl of M&M's since the link in his article is to the Snopes page that exists for the sole purpose of explaining those reasons.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by Fliko on Tuesday November 01, 2011 @12:14PM (#3182753)
Ahh, didn't even notice that, and I have to admit that Kottke's article didn't seem very hate mongering.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by nmcfarl on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:17PM (#3179113)
That's actually covered in the Snopes article Kottke linked to.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by yawn on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:28PM (#3178893)
That's how I read it, too. This whole thing is overblown and Kottke is being used as an excuse for some drama.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by jakejake on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:42PM (#3179223)
I feel like those guys are projecting their own issues onto the situation. I didn't sense any malice in Kottke's post and certainly nothing that I would compare to high-school bullying.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by ajross on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:42PM (#3178944)
How is selectively quoting something from a larger document in order to call it "crazy" not ridicule? That sounds like the very definition of "ridicule", no? If Kottke wanted to go into a discussion about whether or not this kind of rider is helpful or hurtful to RMS's cause, that would be productive. But this is a full-on put down, done in public.

If this isn't ridicule, then what is?

Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by jaylevitt on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:53PM (#3178990)
When I read "crazy and amazing", that "crazy" reads like "wild, man". Not "idiotic".
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman by funkah on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:57PM (#3179005)
Any quoting is going to be selective. What is he going to do, quote the whole thing? Also, Kottke's whole deal is curating unusual, interesting stuff on the web, and I would say this rider is definitely both unusual and interesting. This is just what Kottke does, he points to stuff and says "hey, look at this." Maybe you have a problem with that entire enterprise, in which case fair enough, but he's not doing anything with respect to the rider that he doesn't do for whatever else is on the web that day.

I agree that "crazy" is not exactly high praise, but it's a very overloaded term these days. I don't think it's meant to be as mean as Winer and everyone else is taking it.