News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by tobr on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:59AM (#31787558)
> "Who is it?"

“It” is not used here because we don’t know the gender. Consider “Who is she?” for example, which is a very different question.

> "It was Bob!"

Why wouldn’t we say “He was Bob!” in this case, since the gender is presumably known? Because “He was Bob” and “It was Bob” mean completely different things.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by shwoopdiwoop on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:57PM (#31786931)
You are confidently incorrect.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by bbarnett on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:00PM (#31786945)
Or mayhap I know what difference lay, between it and they?
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by ojkelly on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:09PM (#31786978)
> The Oxford English Dictionary traces singular they back to 1375, where it appears in the medieval romance William and the Werewolf.

https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they...

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:31AM (#31787265)
Yes, but the first sentence of that article reads, "Singular they has become the pronoun of choice to replace he and she in cases where the gender of the antecedent – the word the pronoun refers to – is unknown, irrelevant, or nonbinary, or where gender needs to be concealed."

According to your article, because the name of the actual person, Gustave Eiffel, is known the correct form of address is "Gustave Eiffel". Otherwise, no reader really knows who or how many people "they" references.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by ncmncm on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:20AM (#31790600)
Many others were involved. Likely even some nonbinaries; only the word is a recent invention.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:40AM (#31790842)
What word is a recent invention?
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by ncmncm on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:58AM (#31791034)
"Nonbinary"
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by doctor_eval on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:42PM (#31787086)
soooo...

> Amazingly cool that it understood it had to make the statue handle winds in the harbor.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by the_only_law on Saturday June 18, 2022 @07:52PM (#31794861)
Technically correct, the favorite of pedants.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by na85 on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:02PM (#31786950)
Nah, it's exceedingly common to use "they" as the indefinite gender singular. I remember seeing this in the 90s.

Example: "If a person wishes to avoid jail, they would be wise not to commit crimes."

No other word except the gross "he/she" construction makes grammatical sense in lieu of "they".

[dead]
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by SirSavary on Saturday June 18, 2022 @10:43AM (#31790224)
That's a completely different sentence? This is like arguing that passive voice is always correct and one should never use active voice under any circumstance.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by ncmncm on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:21AM (#31790611)
Maybe look up the definition of "passive voice". It is probably not what you imagine.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:05PM (#31792757)
> This is like arguing that passive voice is always correct and one should never use active voice under any circumstance.

No. It is nothing like that at all.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by na85 on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:43PM (#31787088)
That's not the same sentence, now is it?
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:05AM (#31787177)
It's a more pithy sentence that conveys the same information.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by na85 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:27AM (#31787250)
Despite this new revelation that it's possible to rephrase a sentence to avoid using a word, that's completely orthogonal to my point which is that "they" has been used to indicate the singular person of indeterminate gender for at least 30 years.

I'm honestly not sure what you're trying to demonstrate.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:57PM (#31787157)
> "It" is the gender neutral singular pronoun, "they" is plural.

Not exactly. "They" is not commonly recognized as singlular. While "they" has occasionally been used as a singular in certain instances for at least 700 years, those cases are generally isolated and are considered poor uses of the language.

"It" and "one" are both third-person personal pronouns that are gender neutral. "It" is far from the only gender neutral singular pronoun.

> EG, when someone calls, or is at the door, people often ask "Who is it?"

"Who" is an interrogative pronoun in your sentence, "who is it?" Who is gender neutral but does not have the power to be singular or plural, since it is interrogative.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by bradrn on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:26AM (#31787246)
> Firstly, "they" is not commonly recognized as plural. While "they" has been used in certain instances as plural for at least 700 years, those cases are generally isolated and are considered poor uses of the language not standard usages.

Sorry? ‘They’ is universally recognised as a third-person plural pronoun, and as such it is the standard way to refer to a group of people in English. That it is additionally used as a gender-neutral singular animate pronoun does not change this. If you consider ‘they’ to be non-plural, I would be very interested to know exactly what you do consider to qualify as a third-person plural pronoun in English.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by CharlesW on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:07AM (#31787373)
> ‘They’ is universally recognised as a third-person plural pronoun…

The "singular they" has been in use since the 1300s.

https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they...

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:38AM (#31787302)
You are absolutely 100% correct. It was a sad typo on my part from typing too quickly for my own good. I hope what I wrote is now more cogent. Thank you.
Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by bradrn on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:22AM (#31790631)
Thank you! I appreciate the correction. Unfortunately, I cannot agree with this either:

> "They" is not commonly recognized as singlular.

Personally, I’d say that ‘they’ can act as both a third person animate singular and a third person gender-neutral plural pronoun, in just the same way that ‘you’ is both a second-person singular and second-personal plural pronoun. True, the singular usage of ‘they’ isn’t quite as common as the plural usage, but as a native English speaker I’ve never seen singular ‘they’ as particularly unusual.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:00PM (#31792724)
I understand. There are people who use the singular they. There are even many people who use the singular they. Nobody disputes that, and I doubt anyone would say with any honesty they misunderstood when they is intended to be singular or plural. Maybe in specific scenarios where the rest of the sentence is poorly written, but not overall.

That being said, what I meant by uncommon use is that there are many more people who do not use they as singular compared to those who do. This isn't a value judgement, and languages evolve. The commonly cited OED article is simply a recognition that languages change. I am saying that the singular they is not the common use of the word.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by bradrn on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:05PM (#31795771)
> there are many more people who do not use they as singular compared to those who do

I do accept your point here, but I think even this is debatable. Certainly, there is a population which vociferously denies the validity of singular ‘they’… but are they truly a majority? It’s really hard to know. Personally, I found that usage so natural, I don’t recall even noticing it until it was pointed out to me.

Re:Recently discovered drawings for Statue of Liberty hint a... by IncRnd on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:38PM (#31795941)
I agree that there are extremely standard uses of singular "they", when the pluralty is known.

  "Somebody left their umbrella in the office. Could you
    please let them know where they can get it?"
  "The patient should be told at the outset how much they
    will be required to pay."
  "But a journalist should not be forced to reveal their
    sources."[1]
That was my first comment's point. The comment to which I replied didn't make obvious who "they" referenced. It could have meant the architect, designer, both, or more. It was, "Amazingly cool that they understood they had to make the statue handle winds in the harbor." [2]

I think some people are getting caught up in the mistaken belief that I am being political, when I am talking about writing in understandable sentences.

This is on Merriam-Webster's page on the singular they. "In an 1881 letter, Emily Dickinson wrote 'Almost anyone under the circumstances would have doubted if [the letter] were theirs, or indeed if they were themself.' People have used singular 'they' to describe someone whose gender is unknown for a long time, but the nonbinary use of 'they' is relatively new." [3]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31785507#31795771

[3] https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/singular-nonbi...