News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chicken and the Egg, for 5-year-olds by gus_massa on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:24PM (#31786506)
It's a problem of classification. Imagine you have one of those machines with a red faucet with hot water and a blue faucet with cold water. Then you can classify water as hot or cold and be happy. Until you discover that the temperature of water can be in between. Anyway, if one of your coworkers are going to the machine, you can ask for a glass of cold/hot water and your coworker will understand. It's a useful classification.

Something similar happens with Australopithecus vs Homo. The discussion is easier because Australopithecus are dead. The latest Australopithecus were very similar to early Homos. The threshold is arbitrary, like the threshold between hot and cold water. (Apparently transitions of species are very fast, so it's difficult to find fossils of the intermediate steps. I'm not sure if this is confirmed.)

So if you take a time machine and go to see the transition, you will find some individuals that are difficult to classify. You will not be able to be sure which one is a Australopithecus and which one is a Homo. Perhaps ir you kill them and cut them in pieces, you can apply some arbitrary threshold like 537.2345 cm^3 of brain, but they will not be happy. Moreover, they will not be able to be sure which one of them is a Australopithecus and which one is a Homo, assuming you can explain the arbitrary threshold to them.

I guess it depends on how you build the phylogenetic trees at the individual level.

1) The fist Homo mated with a Australopithecus and some of the children were probably Australopithecus and some Homos. I guess two Homos can mate and have a children that is an Australopithecus. If you mark Homos with a magic invisible painting, they will be mixed with the community and be treated as a normal member of he community and mate with whoever they can. After a while, most will be Homos, but the few remainder Australopithecus will also be just normal members of the community and mate with whoever they can.

Note that in some parts Australopithecus lived for a longer time, until the Homos from other areas arrived. In the early year we probably ignored the difference and mated. Later when the difference were bigger we probably killed them or forced them to go away.

2) You go and find the first Homo, and define that all the offspring are Homo and it doesn't matter with who they mate. So the first one must mate with an Australopithecus and repeat that during a few generations until the they have cousins far enough to mate. Note that they will not realize the transition. It's just a different way to use the magic invisible painting, but they will interact exactly like in the other method.

There are no comments on this comment yet.