Everytime this particular subject comes up, commenters are quick to chime with their experiences or actual messages, and I don't think the quality of the posts was as good on average as you think. Usenet had weirdos, trolls, crazy people, political nutjobs, racists, and plenty of inane posts too. I think you're nostalgic for something that never existed.
I don't recall a lot of moderation and I do recall flame wars. I think most of the moderation was social norms, especially in an environment where many were posting under their own names from university/company/government accounts.
In forums like the old Slashdot or here, users can moderate with varying degrees of skill with their votes, but users of popular subreddits will happily upvote a serial reposter in the thousands before the mods can take action, they have no idea what the rules are, and even will get mad if the mods "oppress" them.
On a side note, I believe Internet usage should be an obligatory subject in school, but not for etiquette, but for common sense and resiliency against manipulation. Add socialization, mental health, and parenting too if you're changing the study plans.
Benefitting from technology and having direct access to the means are not one and the same.
I get to benefit from the interstate highway system but that doesn't mean I can just go and add lanes or off and on ramps wherever I want.
Raising the bar to access doesn't mean people don't get the economic benefit of a connected world. It means speaking your mind in an online forum is hardware than downloading the twitter app and tapping a few buttons.
Remember it's not, "waspy old Conservatives" that keep new housing from being built in San Francisco-- No, it's rich Palo Alto liberals empowered by free market neoliberal power structures that keep guys that wear sock-with-sandals in multi-million dollar homes. Think about it awhile.
With that power comes responsibility. It is on us to promulgate cultural norms to exist in this new world, where we choose to do unto others as we would have done unto us.
Humanity is so new to grappling with these changes -- we are only beginning to understand the impacts and implications inherent to our newly-constructed tools. The world was a simpler and less-connected place when I was a child -- my earliest computer memories include an 8086 and one of the first few 1200 bps modems in our entire town of 30,000 people. Uploading a single image from my smartphone at those rates would, in the best case, take more than five hours.
None of us earned the internet ourselves. It emerged through the uncoordinated efforts of billions of people. We limit access to it at our collective peril.
Ironically people's starting point for "when things became bad" is almost always after they join, so even "seasoned users" disagree on the start of the decline in general. That's the problem with exclusionary rhetoric in almost all walks of life, because the easiest response to any sort of "we're full" rhetoric is and should be "you leave first" and such a response has no real counter.
Compare the R/C plane hobby before and after Drones hit the market. Before quadcopter drones, R/C aircraft were difficult to fly and required an investment of time and discipline to master the skill. This meant the community was fairly small and dedicated. And it was able to effectively self govern for decades with basically no government intervention required.
Then quadcopters hit the market and it took not even 10 years before the FAA had to intervene because idiots who had no skill or respect for the technology were flying around airports, public gatherings and other restricted areas. Even though things practically fly themselves they were crashing into people and their property. There were serious injuries because they were flown by morons.
So the FAA had to step in and become the gatekeeper.
Is crashing a drone into a person's car or a child the same as idiots on social media? No, but irresponsible use of social media has ruined plenty of people's lives. The connect isn't as obvious but the damage is still there.
We haven't started requiring social media licenses because speech is a protected right of course. And we shouldn't change that. But that means there should be some social responsibility.
I think you're underestimating the effort people can put into voicing their opinions, specially if they're controversial, or they built their personality around them.
That said, I understand where you're coming from. The Internet has given a megaphone to every moron on the planet.
In that sense, the majority rarely realise what the internet is [1] and that it's more than just Facebook, Amazon etc.
> It takes no effort to get online and speak your mind so nobody respects the technology.
In my day, you either walked past the crazy person on the street corner and paid no attention to their insane rantings, or you spent several days cutting out letters from a newspaper and glueing them onto A4 before popping in the snail-mail.
Sure I can.
Giving millions of random uneducated whackjobs an equal voice with actual trained medical professionals poses a real threat to public health. That's exactly what's happened.
I really, really hate to say this but I'm beginning to have sympathies with Ayn Rand's literature. We don't let, "normal people" into operating rooms; why is it that the public has been invited to the conversation about complicated things like science, medicine, philosophy, ethics (..?)
Worth relating: https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/708391
I think lowering the bar, to a certain point, has been harmful to society. Its a case of tragedy of the commons. It takes no effort to get online and speak your mind so nobody respects the technology. They don't have to, they didn't earn it. It was given to them. If people had to expend even a little bit of effort to access social media I think they would treat it very differently. And I don't think you have to raise that bar by much at all.