Re:Legendary bacterial evolution experiment enters new era
by failrate on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:15AM
(#31779414)
It demonstrated that the requestor had not put in even the minimum amount of effort to identify the data present in the paper and lacked an understanding of how the entire domain and process worked. It is similar to going into a restaurant, ordering something that is not on the menu, and then being outraged that there's no wonton soup at the hotdog stand.
The second response was also very rude. If someone is screaming at you that their taxes paid for your work, it is never polite.
Re:Legendary bacterial evolution experiment enters new era
by robertlagrant on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:14PM
(#31785095)
Your analogies fall down in that they in no way relate to the tone of what's written there. Unless you mean the second response is analogous to screaming.
Reading it, it seems like the first request was silly, but the second was very straightforward and not rude. The second response was an extreme overreaction to the second request, which did little more than say, "Actually the paper doesn't contain all the data; please may we have the data?"