News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by click170 on Monday October 31, 2011 @09:38AM (#3177298)
This sounds like the kind of thing that some MBA came up with;

Suit: "And in the Terms of Service, add some note so that we can use their personal info for marketing."

Cubicle-ee: "That's a little sleezy and sounds like it may backfire.."

Suit: "Nonsense, nobody reads the ToS and everybody is data mining people's personal info these days, they can't get mad at us without getting mad at everyone else too. Look at Google."

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by bonzoesc on Monday October 31, 2011 @11:20AM (#3177658)
It sounds more like legal:

Suit: "We're collecting this data? Why?"

Cubicle-dweller: "Dunno, seemed useful."

Suit: "Well, we better put something in the ToS about it so our customers know that we're storing it."

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by click170 on Monday October 31, 2011 @02:33PM (#3178461)
If it wasn't for the specific wording in the ToS allowing them to sell your info to marketers, I would be happy giving them that benefit of the doubt.
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by bonzoesc on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:00PM (#3178769)
I couldn't find it in the current Terms of Service, so I expect that they saw the typical /r/gaming histrionics, checked and saw that they hadn't actually sold the info, figured out how much reddit histrionics cost in sales versus the almost-completely-absent demand for information about super-entitled whiny PC gamers, and decided it wouldn't hurt to remove it from the agreement and their business plans.
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by AJ007 on Monday October 31, 2011 @03:45PM (#3178702)
There is actually a case where Sears paid consumers for permission to spy on them and the FTC did not agree it was lawful: http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2009/06/sears.shtm

EA is run by idiots if they think they can get away with this.

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by ryanhuff on Monday October 31, 2011 @09:58AM (#3177361)
Why don't you throw lawyers under the bus while you are at it. After all, we know that everybody but coders are looking to screw the customer.
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by outworlder on Monday October 31, 2011 @10:02AM (#3177371)
Because in most companies, it is the "coders" who are in charge, right?
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by dlikhten on Monday October 31, 2011 @10:40AM (#3177489)
flame/troll bait aside... This was most definitely intentional. EA has demonstrated a lack of giving a shit about customers since Spore and even before that. Spore was a catalyst. They prey on ignorance of users. The truth is by now someone is reading the TOS, and posting about it. The problem is that not everyone reads those posts.

And kids? They don't care about their "privacy" its "gimme mah game!!@?!@!@!@!#%$!" if you disagree with that statement deal with a hormone filled teenager.

Of course those kids who don't get the game will naturally look for hacked alternatives. And this is where EA's lack of understanding of the real world will bite them in the ass.

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by ryanhuff on Monday October 31, 2011 @11:29AM (#3177690)
I have an MBA, I rarely wear a suit, and I have not sold out customers. Also, the majority of EA's management team (including CEO) does not have MBA's. So, at least in this specific example, the dreaded "MBA" label does not seem to be the culprit.
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by click170 on Monday October 31, 2011 @01:29PM (#3178197)
No no, I think you misunderstand my point.

It's the suits job, nay legal obligation in the case of a publicly held company, to maximize profits. More and more frequently we're seeing profits take precedence over privacy and customers, and I don't think that would have been possible as a bottom-up change coming from coders. No, this change came from the top, and coming from the top it spread to the tops of other companies like wildfire.

Also, I have no hesitations about throwing lawyers under the bus as well. They're the front line in the battle that these companies are waging against, what are often times paying customers, never mind that they're paying customers too and that they're ruining the future for our and their own children. What, you think it's just a matter of perspective and a lawyer sees things differently than I do? Show me one lawyer who has no qualms about arguing that a corporation is a person, and I'll show you a person who's sold their soul.

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by anigbrowl on Monday October 31, 2011 @02:16PM (#3178396)
It's the suits job, nay legal obligation in the case of a publicly held company, to maximize profits.

No, it's the suit's job to run the company in the interest of the shareholders. That is not the same thing as 'maximize profits at all costs' (such as, at the cost of future litigation that will exceed the instant profit). This idea that if an opportunity for profit exists, the management is legally obliged to seize it is widespread, but without foundation. Otherwise shareholders would sue large firms for not entering hot new markets where the firms' resources would provide a short-term advantage.

Show me one lawyer who has no qualms about arguing that a corporation is a person, and I'll show you a person who's sold their soul.

Yeah, whatever. without the doctrine of corporate personhood, which lawyers are well aware is a different thing from natural personhood, you wouldn't be able to sue a corporation for malfeasance in the first place, but would have to try suing the officers of the corporation individually while they gave your legal claim the runaround.

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by pyre on Monday October 31, 2011 @03:56PM (#3178752)
Where does the personhood of a lump sum of money[1] come into play here?

[1]: http://dockets.justia.com/docket/connecticut/ctdce/3:2011cv0...

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by anigbrowl on Tuesday November 01, 2011 @03:27AM (#3181022)
It doesn't, for two reasons. One, it has no particular connection to corporate personhood. Two, a case like that is called a proceeding in rem, which is literally 'against a thing.' It used to be called an 'impersonal' action, but my law dictionary says that term's deprecated.

Proceedings in rem are usually for the purpose of determining whether there's sufficient evidence to decide that a piece of property is a component in or the proceeds of crime, even if nobody has been caught. An example would be a drug bust where the criminals flee but leave behind a brick of cocaine and a suitcase full of cash. The government can't just seize the money and spend it; it has to come up with some objectively reasonable argument for why the valuables would be forfeit.

They do publish details of upcoming hearings in advance, so if you see that the government is trying to keep your stuff and you have a really good explanation for why you should get it back (eg it was stolen but you didn't call it in because you were in a coma following the robbery), then you can turn up at the hearing and get custody back.

Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by click170 on Monday October 31, 2011 @02:56PM (#3178532)
I don't think it's so much that people believe corporations have a legal obligation to seize all opportunities for profit, I think it's that many corporations have been behaving in ways that the majority of the population believes is, or should be illegal. The people in charge of these companies are fully aware of the public perception of what they do, but they continue because they know they can get away with it with a few financial donations to some political campaigns here and there.
Re:EA's Origin may be glorified spyware, causes mass upset by ryanhuff on Monday October 31, 2011 @03:42PM (#3178691)
I don't think the vast majority of corporations do what you suggest. On the whole, IMO most corporations (private and public) contribute to the economy and society without being scoundrels.