Re:Why we think there's a Multiverse, not just our Universe
by xenophanes on Sunday October 30, 2011 @01:55AM
(#3173752)
Can you give a statement of what you mean by "empiricism" that you wish to defend?
I agree with some of what you say, but I'm not sure what you're trying to vindicate.
Bear in mind that one can construct infinitely many theories logically consistent with every piece of evidence or empirical check done in the past, and which predict that the grass cure for the cold will work. These theories will consist of various disjointed assertions in a rather arbitrary and ad hoc manner. The problem with these theories is that they are terrible as explanations -- they are bad philosophically -- but they are not empirically refuted.
Re:Why we think there's a Multiverse, not just our Universe
by nu23 on Sunday October 30, 2011 @06:50AM
(#3174077)
My goal was not to defend pure empiricism - that justifications for knowledge can come only from sense data. I just wanted to emphasize that, in your example, when we chose a good explanation instead of a bad one, the goodness of the explanation has a large empirical component.I am guessing that you agree with this but would focus on the non-empirical component.
One non-empirical component of its goodness would be the complexity of its specification, the Kolmogorov complexity for instance.
Almost nothing in science is justified by direct checks. Think of any clinical trial or say, the LHC experiments. There are so many implicitly assumed background theories about how the instruments respond to their stimuli. Some of these instruments are based on principles which were discovered only in this century. So scientists from previous times wouldn't accept the way the results are derived unless they are shown the results derived from previous experiments justifying the way the instruments work. For example, the atomic hypothesis was controversial till 1900 or so. How would one even interpret LHC electron beams if one one doesn't believe in the atomic hypothesis? A useful analogy here, is minesweeper - a new opened square, whose information, via a very long chain can tell us if there is a mine on a far away square.