Re:An Elephant Burial
by wnight on Saturday October 29, 2011 @10:27PM
(#3173450)
Technically, any fallacy is silly.
But no, I wasn't attempting to use a fallacy in support of killing elephants. I was flat-out pointing out that his stance on some killing is hypocritical.
I agree that shooting the elephant was a dick move. I'd just go so far as to extend that to chickens.
Re:An Elephant Burial
by logjam on Saturday October 29, 2011 @10:52PM
(#3173506)
I agree that killing for sport and eating meat are both unnecessary, do harm healthwise on an individual and social scale, and produce much suffering in the world.
But no, I wasn't attempting to use a fallacy in support of killing elephants. I was flat-out pointing out that his stance on some killing is hypocritical.
I agree that shooting the elephant was a dick move. I'd just go so far as to extend that to chickens.