News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Inexplicable War on Lemonade Stands by anigbrowl on Saturday October 29, 2011 @03:49PM (#3172629)
A permit, as defined by Black's law dictionary (paraphrased[1]), is authorization to commit an otherwise criminal/forbidden act. Thus if you had a skulking permit that authorizes you to steal and kill, you legally could commit what was a crime. [...]

[1]: I had to paraphrase because I don't own a copy. I had to look it up in the library a while ago, and the definition stuck with me.

I do own a copy and it says no such thing, or even anything like it. I find this memory highly dubious, because permits are given for administrative matters, violation of which can incur a fee or a fine or a requirement of specific performance, but which most certainly cannot land you in jail or result in criminal liability. Historically the word derives from the French per mitter le droit which means 'for passing the right' [to a piece of real estate].

The phrase 'real estate' itself derives from French meaning 'royal estate'; back when all land was legally owned by the aristocracy, long-term renewable land rents were issued, some of which specified the acceptable use of the land - hence the word 'landlord.' In many places in Europe it's still common to buy a house but have to pay a (nominal) rent to someone who owns the underlying land, although this is nowadays a private individual or land investment company rather than an aristocrat. Real estate transactions in the US typically involve both the land and the buildings on it, but not always. Even back in the early days of the US state governments often retained some rights over the land granted or sold, such as the right to 'royalties' on mineral extraction.

I think you may have mis-remembered what you read, but Black's Law Dictionary has been through 9 editions. If you can remember when this was or anything else related to the research, I would be interested in looking it up at the university law library. As it is, I think you're mistaken. If one wanted to give permission for an activity that is normally criminal (possession of drugs by a medical researcher, say), one would seek immunity.

Re:The Inexplicable War on Lemonade Stands by trebor on Saturday October 29, 2011 @07:07PM (#3173087)
Yeah, I think I'm mistaken about the definition of Permit—though I know I looked up a similar word that had the definition I gave. Maybe I mixed it with definition with that of License. I'd studied both words out of curiosity and it's been around a year since I did so.

If one wanted to give permission for an activity that is normally criminal (possession of drugs by a medical researcher, say), one would seek immunity.

How would you be granted such immunity? As a license, or as a permit? ;)

Re:The Inexplicable War on Lemonade Stands by anigbrowl on Saturday October 29, 2011 @08:31PM (#3173253)
License seems a lot closer to the sense of what you were talking of originally. Don't know why I didn't think of that; maybe because it run with the person rather than the land.