News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eric S. Raymond: Why Alternative Energy Isn’t by wheels on Saturday September 27, 2008 @10:55AM (#316924)
As noted below, his versions (or contributions) to most of those software projects were all pretty trivial. And listing "projects" like hexdump is kind of cute -- it's 211 lines of code.

The one claim that stood out there -- the one that gave a really testable statement that would have surprised me if true was, "ESR is the second biggest lisp contributor to Emacs after RMS". I thought, hey, there'd be a surprise, so I decided to run cvstat on the emacs lisp subdir:

  - RMS contributed the 2nd most code to Emacs' Lisp with 217542 lines of changes.
  - ESR contributed the 39th most code to Emacs' Lisp with 6367 lines of changes.
The reason that I don't like the guy so much is because he claims to speak for a movement, that by his own prognostication is a meritocracy, and I don't feel like he has the credibility for that. Combined with the fact that I think a lot of what he says is bozo-riffic, I'd prefer him step back from his self-appointed spokesman position.

There are no comments on this comment yet.