News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physicists discover never-before seen particle sitting on... by godelski on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:13PM (#31687618)
I'm a bit confused by the article here. The author states

> The authors, who begin their abstract with

>> The observation of the Higgs boson solidified the standard model of particle physics. However, explanations of anomalies (for example, dark matter) rely on further symmetry breaking, calling for an undiscovered axial Higgs mode.

> which has nothing to do with the result in their paper.

But also in the abstract is

> Here, we discover an axial Higgs mode in the CDW system RTe3 using the interference of quantum pathways

Similarly, they call out a tweet that is actually by the last author of the paper which states the discovery of a new particle.

> Excited to report our latest @Nature discovery of __a new particle__, the Axial Higgs mode

So I'm not confused about the skepticism of discovering an Axial Higgs mode, but the article is about hype not the experiment. They should at least add that the author and lab is accountable as well as giving some evidence why this experiment is wrong. I'm not a particle physicist so I can't really make conjectures as to if the experiment is right or wrong, but considering that the authors are claiming to discover a new particle I'm not sure I really blame the media in this case (despite the overall messaging resonating with me as I see this happen a lot in my current field: ML). I agree that it doesn't look like a new particle is discovered here, but I think the authors are culpable here. Similarly Nature, where the reviewers should have had this foresight.

Re:Physicists discover never-before seen particle sitting on... by mr_toad on Thursday June 09, 2022 @08:07PM (#31688495)
Re:Physicists discover never-before seen particle sitting on... by godelski on Thursday June 09, 2022 @09:22PM (#31688905)
The tweet by the lab advisor literally said "new particle" (emphasis was my own to highlight this). I understand what you're saying, but I'm saying that the lab made a grave error.
Re:Physicists discover never-before seen particle sitting on... by mr_toad on Thursday June 09, 2022 @10:27PM (#31689301)
I’m assuming they mean a quasiparticle or excitation