The entire "impact" consisted of the significance that Apple is getting into that space: a company with a powerful brand backed by a history of delivering popular consumer tech. I'm sure that wasn't lost on Malda; but his remarks at the moment were about the specs (the what, not the who). There was no reason for a non-Apple-fanatic to get that iPod.
I didn't say he (or the statement I compared to his) were wrong.
I said they missed the point of what was important for impact.