News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by chubot on Thursday October 27, 2011 @08:31PM (#3166313)
So he's right? Every response on this thread seems to be ad hominem. No one seems to be defending AirBNB guys.

It is relevant because any online business necessarily has a lot of information about its customers. Spamming is both illegal and immoral (free riding on the commons), so I would choose not to give my business/info to people with a known history of such activity.

Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by badclient on Thursday October 27, 2011 @08:45PM (#3166372)
Spamming is not illegal. That is the biggest lie out there, actually. You just have to adhere to some specific requirements when sending unsolicited email.

Also, spamming may be against many company's TOS but that does not make it illegal.

Go read the CAN-SPAM Act.

Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by chubot on Thursday October 27, 2011 @08:50PM (#3166391)
Whatever, that's splitting hairs and not relevant to the main point.

If someone is writing a program to send out unsolicited e-mails on behalf of other parties, it's pretty unlikely that they're doing the due diligence. I don't know what happened but I think it's funny that all the responses are "Aaron Greenspan is a whiny loser".

Also, I don't read any company's TOS when deciding whether to do business with them. Do you? I go by their reputation. If a company has a bad reputation then it makes me less likely to do business with them.

Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by badclient on Thursday October 27, 2011 @09:01PM (#3166424)
If a company has a bad reputation then it makes me less likely to do business with them.

Except if I read a bad review about a company from someone who has a record of bad experiences with companies, I do not take that person's review into account and discard it as an outlier. Aaron Greenspan has a pretty solid history of being that guy who has a problem with almost everyone of stature that he has come to know.

Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by haliax on Thursday October 27, 2011 @11:03PM (#3166802)
IT was pretty clear from the story about AirBNB spam that they did not adhere to those requirements, in any way.
[deleted]
Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by chubot on Thursday October 27, 2011 @08:56PM (#3166416)
Haha, funny. But in this case it is the refutation of the argument that has the fallacy.

So there is the original argument that he's a spammer, which hasn't been refuted. And there is the ad hominem counter-argument which is refuted by being ad hominem.

So I think I am still justified in believing the original argument without contrary evidence. So really you are profering a fallacist's fallacist's fallacy. :)

Re:Allegations of past and present Internet crime haunt Airb... by jessedhillon on Friday October 28, 2011 @01:06AM (#3167069)
So there is the original argument that he's a spammer, which hasn't been refuted.

Are you aware that the burden of proof rests on the claimant? Unless you have convincing evidence supporting a claim, you are not logically justified in accepting it.