The big difference here was that the Mac had been around for ten years, had a big user base (even if small relative to windows) and sustainable compelling advantages over its competitors (best versions of most graphics apps, only versions of some, many unique media apps (e.g avid, protools), real multiple monitor support, system level color management). If WebOS had ten years of history and a bunch of industry leading apps on it the analogy might be stronger.
Re:HP to Keep PC Division
by ScottBurson on Thursday October 27, 2011 @06:34PM
(#3165928)
In fairness, HP never proposed to "kill one of its largest sources of revenue". The idea was to get some cash by selling or spinning off a relatively low-margin division. Killing it would be ridiculous. IBM certainly didn't "kill" its PC division; Lenovo is now the #2 vendor.
Re:HP to Keep PC Division
by firefoxman1 on Thursday October 27, 2011 @11:16PM
(#3166833)
While IBM wasn't nearly the world's biggest PC maker as HP is right now, I would like to see a similar deal happen with WebOS. Lenovo has proven to manage the thinkpad line better than IBM[1].
[1] http://www.tmcnet.com/topics/articles/229026-hp-remains-bigg...
webOS doesn't have a steve jobs, or else it might still be around.
Re:HP to Keep PC Division
by firefoxman1 on Thursday October 27, 2011 @11:08PM
(#3166813)
Agreed. That's why I would love to see it in the hands of Bezos and team.
In my opinion, it's much better than iOS for tablets and larger devices (the perfect TV?) but the clock is ticking. Every day HP wastes with decisions like "should we kill one of our largest sources of revenue?" Apple is right next door developing amazing products for tomorrow like Siri.