Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by cryptoz on Thursday October 27, 2011 @02:28PM
(#3164721)
They probably don't want an expensive solution that takes ages to develop and implement. What they're looking for is a cheap, easy-to-deploy-in-the-field solution. The prize attracts a different type of applicant with different methods and tools.
Edit: To clarify: A prize of $1 million may result in everyone spending $100,000 to find the solution quickly, when in fact DARPA only wants solutions that can be developed at a price well under $50,000.
Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by brador on Thursday October 27, 2011 @03:17PM
(#3165011)
I disagree. If they want cheap and easy to deploy, add it to the spec. As it is, a prize is offered to get the attention of talent. $50K won't get the attention of anyone even remotely talented enough to produce "best of show" solutions. I suggest $1million will get their attention.
Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by VladRussian on Thursday October 27, 2011 @05:00PM
(#3165523)
they don't want a million dollar solution. Among other goals, they want to know what a solution can a 3rd party get at this market and technology state on a budget of $50K scale. Ie. how sound the DoD shredding practices is.
Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by nodata on Friday October 28, 2011 @02:18AM
(#3167230)
The finished product will likely be something that can automate photo taking and a laptop.
The amount of money DARPA pays to get the know-how has no connection at all to the price of the finished product.
Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by kevinalexbrown on Thursday October 27, 2011 @03:37PM
(#3165107)
It's more about generating publicity for DARPA than an actual solution. Just look at the website design and the language. I mean seriously, a forum?
Most public DARPA projects are awarded via grant application from serious labs, and the funding often goes out before you reach a solution, since they fund high-risk projects with a low enough likelihood of a solution that profit-seeking companies won't want to try it otherwise.
Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by VladRussian on Thursday October 27, 2011 @04:43PM
(#3165437)
>I mean seriously, a forum?
it sounds like you somehow missed the Grand Challenge trilogy.
Re:DARPA: reconstruct shredded documents, win $50,000
by InclinedPlane on Thursday October 27, 2011 @05:37PM
(#3165688)
I would say it is certainly technically possible with modern tech, but seriously...$50k?
Change the prize to a million dollars and you'd get a solution overnight.