[deleted]
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by mentat on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:23PM
(#3164289)
In other words he doesn't feel empathy. Smart people tend to flip the bozo bit on the world. Put simply, that's very dangerous because when your principles are more important than anything else and when you can't see the pain you cause to others, significant human harm is possible if not likely.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by pork on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:28PM
(#3164329)
Actually in a previous HN thread about exactly this (you can pull it out from my comments), someone referenced an interview where stallman mentions that he's slightly autistic. For those who don't know, a lack of empathy is a symptom of autism, so I wouldn't attribute all this to him being malicious or mean.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by mentat on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:31PM
(#3164339)
I wasn't making a judgment about the causes for the lack of empathy but rather what its effects tend to be. Someone who doesn't see people as people is capable of things that others are not. Some of those things are good, other are scary.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by pork on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:41PM
(#3164401)
As someone who has an autistic person in their life, you have to understand that they think differently, and that can often seem scary to us because we value empathy so much in a society. I just think we should cut him some slack in the light of the fact that he very likely can't see it another way. If he were a sociopath, which IS scary, trust me -- we wouldn't know it.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by meric on Thursday October 27, 2011 @08:04PM
(#3166217)
Did you mean Steve Jobs, with "bozo" decisions like "no floppies for iMac", "Only phones with only one button"?
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by mentat on Thursday October 27, 2011 @08:27PM
(#3166298)
Actually I'd say Steve Jobs was very empathetic in terms of his ability to see what regular people would want to use and what would be confusing to them. From what I read he chose not to use those skills with coworkers, employees, etc. Nonetheless I think he clearly had them. Whether that makes him "worse" than RMS is a highly subjective question.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by gujk on Friday October 28, 2011 @01:20AM
(#3167102)
Jobs had empathy but not sympathy.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by jhuni on Thursday October 27, 2011 @02:07PM
(#3164592)
This applies to everyone, not just Stallman. You can't expect people to feel empathy for everyone in a world as connected as ours, it would be overwhelming.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by mentat on Thursday October 27, 2011 @02:18PM
(#3164666)
The empathy necessary to imagine the state of mind of someone who has just lost someone that they looked up to is not really that deep. You're laying out a straw man here. I'm not saying that people are required to have empathy with everyone. Nonetheless it's not unrealistic to expect some for a relatively common situation (death).
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by jsavimbi on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:25PM
(#3164298)
Posting the sanitized contents of a private/claimed email exchange is not okay.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by vgrichina on Thursday October 27, 2011 @03:40PM
(#3165126)
Isn't Stallman all for sharing and openness?
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by jsavimbi on Thursday October 27, 2011 @04:41PM
(#3165427)
Regardless of the origin of the words or their perceived context, it's widely considered unacceptable to publicly post the content of private emails and subsequently attribute authorship. It's not the doing thing.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by vgrichina on Thursday October 27, 2011 @04:46PM
(#3165445)
I understand this and I won't do such thing myself, what I mean is in case of Stallman he would be hypocritical if he's against it.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by _delirium on Thursday October 27, 2011 @05:43PM
(#3165725)
Stallman's in favor of software users having the right to modify their software and redistribute it. He's not some kind of "information wants to be free" cyberpunk, and doesn't have similar opinions in general. For example, he thinks it's perfectly fine for books to be copyrighted.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by vgrichina on Thursday October 27, 2011 @07:24PM
(#3166082)
IMO that's exactly being hypocritical. Why book users should be prevented from modifying and redistributing them if software users are allowed this right? That simply makes no sense.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by _delirium on Thursday October 27, 2011 @07:49PM
(#3166168)
His argument, which seems pretty reasonable to me, is that software is a tool, whereas books are expression, and sees a stronger argument for it being important that people be able to modify their own tools (he does include some kinds of "tool-like" books, like instruction manuals, in that category).
I don't think it's useful to charge people with "hypocrisy" as an attempt to preemptively shut down debate about whether different classes of works ought to be treated differently, in any case.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by deadcyclo on Thursday October 27, 2011 @11:06PM
(#3166808)
AFAIK, based on the last talk by RMS I attended he condoned copyright on works of fiction only, not on works of fact. So no copyright on manuals, textbooks, scientific articles, etc.
Re:Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
by dsfasdfdfd on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:25PM
(#3164295)
I'm sure that he does not appreciate you posting his email, but thanks for sharing.