News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Jobs book by Tloewald on Thursday October 27, 2011 @12:36PM (#3163989)
I like your suggestions for a more tech savvy bio, but like the grandparent I think Isaacson has done a pretty good job. I totally agree that so much of the story has become rehearsed myth that it's kind of annoying to see it regurgitated here and there although, to give one example, I think Isaacson does a great job of dealing with the relationship between Woz and jobs when so many others simply accept Woz's evolving "standard version".
Re:The Jobs book by davewiner on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:15PM (#3164237)
I didn't say you shouldn't read it -- I didn't even say I wouldn't finish it myself. I just said why it was painful for me to read it. And why the story is so well-rehearsed, and how the myth has replaced the actual events. So many people are reading so much more into what I wrote than what I actually wrote (and think).
Re:The Jobs book by danso on Thursday October 27, 2011 @01:58PM (#3164545)
Can you give any concrete example of where Issacson's apparently shoddy reporting has led to a well-rehearsed myth replaced the actual events?

Instead of complaining about how non-insiders keep trumpeting up "bullshit", help shed light on the truth.

Re:The Jobs book by danilocampos on Thursday October 27, 2011 @02:19PM (#3164673)
> And why the story is so well-rehearsed, and how the myth has replaced the actual events.

Your post would be much more valuable had you provided even one concrete example of this.

Re:The Jobs book by jseliger on Thursday October 27, 2011 @12:47PM (#3164052)
Right. To some extent, the review is criticizing something Isaacson pretty clearly didn't set out to do—explain technology. Isaacson wants to look at Jobs's contradictions and paradoxes—the kindness and cruelty in a single package, indifference tempered by sudden engagement, a frequently binary worldview, the lack of consistency from the outside, the habits that we'd normally dismiss as bizarre, like dietary ones, that might also be tied to success.

Now, I can understand why someone might not be interested in those things, but to me that doesn't invalidate the book.

BTW, I started it and wrote about the first 50 or so pages here: http://jseliger.com/2011/10/24/the-steve-jobs-biography . Note that the book itself is actually nicely and well-made; it feels like a Jobesian artifact, instead of the usual publishing industry pablum.