You’re right; in Germany, insult is illegal. I’m reading about it, and articles say that the majority of minor insults are not reported, and that generally insult claims are dismissed (for example https://www.latimes.com/world/europe/la-fg-germany-insult-la...) Nazism and Holocaust denial are also illegal, and for pretty good reasons. Since the OP’s comment didn’t mention insulting people, but simply having opinions and discussing them, perhaps this is what they’re referring to? That might be the only subject that is taboo without qualification, the rest of them (such as blasphemy) appear to hinge on whether it could affect the safety of people?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_the_Federal_Repu...
The US has similar restrictions, most of them for similar reasons.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...
Watching Bill Maher first time was a eye opener for me on free speech. I couldn't imagine anyone doing it in my own country.
Probably OP is referring to Nazi stuff. But people do get fined for showing birdie at protests. Even though most are dismissed the process of going through the system is the punishment if you have no legal insurance.
All in all, I agree Germany is not a restrictive society and has honours tenets of free speech. But i won't compare it to USA. Which is light years ahead.
I am not supporting that kind of law or anything as I have no skin in the game :).