Re:Ask HN: Apple iOS app rejection - what now?
by daviding on Thursday October 27, 2011 @11:30AM
(#3163615)
Thanks for that. The third option is exactly how we did the app, i.e. no sign up or pay link, just a login. Plus we very prominately say 'You need an active subscription'.
We obviously wouldn't want the 1-star reviews, but in some ways it's ok as the phone app is really just a utility helper for then main task at hand (photos) so it's not as if the app is useful without the subscription.
Do you have any app examples of the third option we could cite?
So you basically have 3 viable choices. The first is to offer in-app subscriptions, and live with the 30% cut that Apple takes. Note that this option is going to be the most convenient for your users, if you care about that sort of thing.
The second is to offer in-app purchasing for 43% more than the regular price. After Apple's 30% cut, this will leave you with the original subscription amount. Note that this is not particularly user-friendly because they're now paying 43% more for the same service.
The third is to remove any and all links to your site from the app. Make it very clear in your app description that this app requires an active subscription, and live with the fact that some users are braindead and will give you 1 star because your app doesn't work for them (because they don't have a subscription).