News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cycles by jacques_chester on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @08:54PM (#3161151)
> I just want to understand the reasons behind the reaction.

Did you read what I wrote? Let me put it in the simplest possible terms.

You haven't been depressed.

You don't know what it's actually like.

Your list of exercises would not work for a depressed person and by thinking that it will you perpetuate the impression that depressed people are just 'putting it on' to garner sympathy and attention.

Depression is a serious condition that ought to be given medical attention.

Your list would appeal to non-sufferers, who might try to foist it on sufferers. What non-sufferers should be doing is dragging sufferers to see a doctor.

Insofar as advice like yours prevents people seeking help for themselves or others, it is actively harmful.

Re:Cycles by EGreg on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @11:49PM (#3161554)
I guess I intend this list to be used as a set of tools. Just like recommending aspirin or mucinex to relieve symptoms does not mean people shouldn't see a doctor to see if they can't be prescribed antibiotics. What is the reason to treat depressed people specially so that this reasoning doesn't apply there too?

As a side question -- and I am really just trying to find out more -- you are extremely confident that depression must be given medical attention and only medical attention. Can you elaborate on that? What specifically do you mean by this? Is it a well known condition that can be treated in all cases? Or is it a cargo-cult-science type thing where some things are treated but over half the cases are just handwaving? When a psychologist says "you should see me again, how about next week" how do you know they are actually helping? etc. When a psychiatrist prescribes a drug, how do you know people wouldn't be cured without it? I am just asking how do you know, because I really want to have more information about it. And since you seem confident I want to ask what you know about this condition. Is it one specific disease or is it just a general guessing game by the experts, kind of like the drugs in these studies: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/12/13/101213fa_fact_...