I don't know enough to form a proper opinion whether or not this is the case.
Of course part of the problem is defining HFT or algorithmic trading. If you build a robot to press an appropriate button at a trading terminal really fast, is that algorithmic, HFT, and should that be banned? Do you fix the tax at 10 cents, and if so how do you react if companies just create massive securities worth millions of dollars and trade those?
I have no idea whether this would actually be a good thing or not, though.
There's also a subset of algorithmic trading that inserts large stop-loss orders (not much of an algorithm there, it's just done by computer program instead of an individual), which have been known to cause flash crashes.
Hence the confusion and belief that by eliminating HFT we'll eliminate automatic stop-loss orders.
The possibility of HFT raises the barriers of entry. Therefore it causes at least some bad.
Personally, I think the markets should just operate at, say, 15 minute heartbeats. Anybody is open to place orders at any point in time in secret. Then, at a predetermined heartbeat time, all orders are revealed and some standard auctioning mechanism is used to match them up against each other.
Sure, spreads would be larger than they are now, but at the same time there would also be less volatility by definition. More importantly, barriers of entry would be much lower, which will cause the market to function closer to a "perfect market" over time.
This is a topic where the critics, who argue in favor of the status quo are at an advantage, because the realities of HFT are not easily discernable to the layman, and require a much deeper understanding of the entire modern financial ecosystem. Suffice to say, there were/are pros and cons to having a specialist.
Let's not go there. Specialists were accused of favoritism: filling orders that certain traders submitted and ignoring requests from other traders.
More generally, the advancements, both in technology and in pricing, actually helped everyone. SOES (small order entry system) helped smaller traders to quickly trade. Decimalization really helped reduce transactions costs (spread between bid and offer is a sort of transaction cost, when we were dealing with 1/16th quoting, the spread cost was over 6 cents)
On another front, brokers used to screw people over by telling people they bought at one price while actually buying at a lower price. This is why Regulation NMS came about. And HFTs nowadays help keep all of the exchange prices in line, minimizing the potential damage of shady broker behavior.
"At least with a specialist, everyone was relatively even in that regard." <-- again, specialists were accused of playing favorites. That's manifestly unfair.
"I can literally create an unfair system by owning the closest supercomputer." <-- That's also not true. It's not good enough to have the lowest latency connection. I can have a slightly slower connection but still have an edge. To put numbers to this, lets say that I was 100 microseconds slower than the fastest person, but I could predict the next price movement 150 microseconds faster (this is due to many factors, including the particular model I use and other implementation details). Then, I would still have a 50 microsecond edge.
"my 'compromise' tax is pretty damn fair considering" <-- this would absolutely screw large funds. As was mentioned by many others, if you tax transactions, market makers will quote wider spreads (and yes, spreads are transactions costs to the large funds moving in and out of positions)
"I'm arguing that there was a cost to removing the specialists, it's obvious now, and we should fix it." <-- NYSE parity (which is a vestige of the specialists) is broken and unfair. Why should someone who sent an order after me get filled before me? Most exchanges have a price-time priority concept, so that if we are sending at the same price but I sent first, then I should get my fill first. The specialists wrecked the idea back then and the current implementation is still unfair.
"the system is just as corrupt now as it was then, just differently." <-- it's actually much less corrupt. I recommend you go and try to build your own HFT, and then you will see that the system now is much more fair than you think. (shameless plug: I started blogging about my experience: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2835656 )
Fact: when you make a large trade, there is a price impact. I.e., if you sell lots of GOOG, the price goes down.
Once upon a time, large funds could use their own sophisticated algorithms to make sure their unsophisticated counterparties feel the price impact. I.e., the big fund disguises their intent, Joe IRA buys from the large fund, and then the price goes down after Joe already owns the stock.
Nowadays, HFT makes the price impact happen immediately, typically splitting the difference with Joe [1].
Why is this worse?
[1] The HFT's try to outbid the large fund in order get ahead of it, resulting in Joe getting a better price.
We know that markets aren't perfect or else Buffet and other value investors couldn't survive. Does HFT make markets more or less perfect at pricing? Does this matter for making markets more efficient in reality, not some hypothetical perfect market?