News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by doubled112 on Friday June 03, 2022 @09:39AM (#31608096)
One less derailleur to adjust or have fail, so less maintenance.

No worries about chain angle in certain gear combinations.

Front chain ring can be cheaper/more durable/flippable because it doesn't need ramps/pins/grooves.

I did a 3x8 to 1x8 conversion on a hard tail mountain bike I was commuting on a while back (~8 years ago). There was some messing around with chain line, but over all a simpler setup when I was done.

I'd bet it is even simpler to get done now.

Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 03, 2022 @10:08AM (#31608481)
Funny enough cross chaining on 1x tends to be worse if you want to get enough range out of the back (1x12/13). That combined with how thin chains are getting to accommodate the big cassettes makes me feel like the limit of 1x will be reached soon.
Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by doubled112 on Friday June 03, 2022 @10:53AM (#31609111)
That's probably true.

I stuck with 8 back then because it's good enough, and the more thin and precise things get, the more expensive yet less tolerant of road salt they seem to become.

2x13 seems like more ratios than I'd ever need, but who am I to say that applies to everybody?

Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by deebosong on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:21PM (#31611124)
Dang. That's kinda of a big deal...

Kinda crazy that people are vouching for 1x if cross-chaining is an issue with that system (as the main pull seemed to be that 1x is fully functional as is, without hiccups).

So in your opinion, do you prefer 2x & 3x? And is the cross-chaining issue with 1x enough of an issue to write it off?

I'm guessing the cross-chaining can be addressed if you reduce the range in the cassette?

Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:31PM (#31611249)
Yeah! Smaller cassettes can help. The difference in efficiency is quite small from testing Lenard Zinn did. About 8w difference. So I’d say especially for mountain biking it makes a lot of sense. For the road where someone might care about marginal gains it makes no sense IMO but to each their own!

As far as 2x vs. 3x, it depends on purpose for me. My rando bike has a triple on it and my faster road bike has a subcompact double. I think if you care about weight savings you can get really good range out of a 2x system. 3x could be more useful for a “do anything” kind of bike.

Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday June 03, 2022 @11:19AM (#31609500)
> One less derailleur to adjust or have fail, so less maintenance.

Theoretically, this is true. Except that the derailleur that 1x design removes is the front derailleur, not well known as the locus of failure or maintainance.

Re:Shimano Forces Hammerhead to Remove All Di2 Related Funct... by doubled112 on Friday June 03, 2022 @11:49AM (#31609954)
Two words: road salt.

Suddenly I realized that my front derailleur was merely a chain guide.

I was really unkind to my bicycles. Always trying to find a way to replace fewer parts. I've broken or worn out and replaced everything except the frame, seat post and handlebars on that bike.