There is a big difference between "here is what I think the authors did wrong" and "I did not read the paper, but did they even account for <obvious thing>?".

The former is perfectly fine and encouraged. The latter is incredibly rude and derails discussions.

Relatedly, you took the rule incredibly literally just so you could critize a strawman...

> Unlike most people, I...

Yes, yes, you a very smart and everyone else, in particular me, is an idiot...