News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by gringoDan on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:58PM (#31585608)
For a related application of this concept, highly recommend The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas, by Ursula LeGuin (10 min read).

http://shsdavisapes.pbworks.com/f/Omelas.pdf

Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by intrepidhero on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:42PM (#31586281)
That was beautiful and poinant, typical of Le Guin. Thank you.

I read once about a young man who wanted to give away everything he had and go live with the poor and destitute. His uncle told him it would be much more compassionate if he got a job, made alot of money and have that away. I've thought about that alot. His uncle wasn't wrong. If we want to improve humanity as a whole we need alot more people working hard making a lot of money to improve things for everyone. But if no one gives everything away and goes to live in poverty... Something good is lost.

Someone down thread mentioned the obvious solution to the trolley problem being saving more lives. I agree, and also, someone has got to rail against the injustice of whole trolley situation to begin with.

Maybe what I'm trying to say is ethical utility can be good, and we should strain to be better.

Just my random thoughts after reading above.

Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by hydrok9 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @05:53PM (#31588624)
*poignant
[dead]
Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by shuntress on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @04:35PM (#31587707)
I think you are missing the point...

"Give away what you can" is obviously the optimal middle ground between "give away nothing" and "give away everything".

Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by slothtrop on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @08:53PM (#31590043)
You can give away everything, and it certainly was the point - it's unambiguous. The word "everything" is there.

There's always a deliberate conflation between want and need. If an action like that has any value, it can't be in the utilitarian sense. It's monastic. And you can decide whether that "purifies your soul" or whatever else, but it's quite a contrivance to suggest it could help others more than funding charity, or better yet voting for progressive policies.

Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by renewiltord on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @07:34PM (#31589496)
Personally, I aspire to be as philanthropic as Bill Gates. Everything past my first billion, I shall share.
Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by Arete314159 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:48PM (#31598994)
I used to really look up to him. But he chose to hang out with a convicted child sex abuser, so now I really question whether somebody with, at the very least, extremely poor judgement and empathy should be leading philanthropic missions. I'd rather just have the gov't tax him and have us vote on how to use that money (I understand that doesn't always work in reality, but at least it works in theory, whereas a guy who hangs out with sex traffickers is not somebody I want talking about how to help 'women in poverty in the third world').
Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by routerl on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:26PM (#31586012)
Great recommendation, and has the same moral premise as Snowpiercer (for a more recent take on this concept).
Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by sonofhans on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:27PM (#31586046)
What a nice recommendation in this context! This is a great story. My first encounter with it was LeGuin herself reading it as a guest in a PSU science fiction class, 25 years ago.
Re:John Rawls and the “Veil of Ignorance” (2020) by Sophistifunk on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @10:50PM (#31590732)
God I hate drivel like this. There's no insight to be found here. These people can only exist in fiction and have no information with which to adjust the bearing on our moral compasses, which have evolved to function only in a universe where effects have causes.