Your mention about /fit/ reminded me of the infamous Bodybuilding.com forum. Such a legendary place, and looks like it still ain't dead yet, far from it.
EDIT: to add another recommendation: https://bogleheads.org/forum/index.php - Personal investments, financial independence
So, basically, with reddit it's very much luck. I still use r/analog and r/londoncycling, but most of the other ones I accept are just meme subs.
Forums are great if you can find a good one for your purpose.
I use https://www.lfgss.com/ for cycling in and around london.
I also follow https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/ for money tips in the UK.
Controversial, but I think forums are better than subreddits, as there is less chance that you will get an influx of people who are not really interested in your stuff. If something hits r/all, you might get a lot of people controbuting to your sub that probably shouldn't be.
Finally, 4chan isn't half bad on some boards... /mu/ is kinda fun, as is /fit/