This analysis assumes he is wrong. I’ve got no idea if he is right or wrong.
But if he is right, Google would probably want to suppress stories like this for PR purposes. “Google AI published in Nature is actually beaten by old commercial technology” is not the headline Google wants to put out.
Although again - I’m not saying that he is right! Just that Google has commercial reasons for what it decides to pursue/implement/publish.
"We find that RePlAce [non AI] produces 26% better wirelength than RL [reinforcement learning] whilst using 5 orders of magnitude less computation"
If that's true then you can see why he criticized the Nature paper. It's not a small difference in performance. The classical techniques are just crushing the AI in this paper.
Maybe I’m being too cynical about press releases though!
We've seen time and again that various trends in ML turn out to have actually been dead-ends.
A few examples: https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.06356 https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.03678
That said, I've also seen plenty of competitive drama in FAANG research labs, so this story is not hard to believe. More senior engineers often will use their seniority to power-grab control of projects. It sounds like Google execs did the right thing in the end.
Also, if you're actually interested in writing a paper on "What are the best techniques for place and route" then write a paper "Best Modern Place and Route algorithms" not "Here's why this particular paper my colleagues wrote is wrong".
Personally, I think they should've published his paper - they can continue actually using the work internally to improve their TPU designs whilst he publicly tries to persuade their competitors it's a bad idea.