I'm not one to claim that anything that goes against the grain is good, but in this case I'd say there's 0 reason to chastise your taste. Not only did you do extensive tests to see what exactly you like, you've also managed to find something to appreciate in a largely dismissed thing. In my book, that's a great thing all around - the spirit of discovery mixed with a unique palate.

PS. But I'll keep drinking my hipster juice, simplicity is enough for me.