Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by planetsprite on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @03:58AM
(#31567090)
The negativity over Dall-e's failures to make perfect images reminds me of the Louis CK stand up about the guy pissed about in-flight wifi not working, basically you're angry about not having this amazing technology you didn't know existed until this very moment.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by Tenoke on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @05:42AM
(#31567600)
Negativity? The post is pretty optimistic and shows amazement of the general technology. Should people not talk about the failure modes and the places where it is subpar?
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by jvm_ on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:52AM
(#31568481)
People adapt to getting an upgrade in life almost immediately. If you walked down the street and someone handed you $80 and the next guy $100, you'd be mad that he got more even though you just got free $$.
It takes 2 weeks to adapt to a loss though.
Humans are strange.
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by evandale on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @11:32AM
(#31570717)
I'm trying to fix this aspect of myself. I was bowling in a tournament over the weekend that was way out of my league but I wanted the challenge. I was struggling all day and got kinda mad because I missed a really easy spare in my first good game of the day.
Lucky for me the guy on the other team was so positive and a much better bowler than me and he asked "That's ok, would you have been happy if I told you at the start of the game you'd have 107 in the 5th?" and I realized hell yeah I'd be happy. Same applies here. Of course I should be happy with a free $80 even if I know everyone else is getting $100.
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by sammorrowdrums on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @04:25AM
(#31567227)
I frequently reference Louis CK bit. It is so frequently applicable.
That said, I think it’s also a compliment to a tool when it does such a good job, that people criticise it for not doing a perfect job. The fact it’s actually doing the job at all is pretty wonderful. I thoroughly enjoyed seeing the results.
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by meheleventyone on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:20AM
(#31567845)
It depends a lot on what you think a good job actually looks like. This sort of prompt based regurgitation and remixing of data sets is super cool from a technical perspective and will maybe be useful one day but from someone mildly interested in this being an actual tool it needs to bridge that last 10%. That doesn't mean it has to be perfect at all. Which seems like a general summation of a lot of ML.
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by ekianjo on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:07AM
(#31567762)
erm the article is not negative at all. It does a good job of explaining what works well and what does not.
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by sheepybloke on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @08:50PM
(#31590024)
I appreciated the discussion because most of the different posts I have read were about how amazing and life changing Dall-e was. This felt more like, "Wow, this is amazing, but it's not perfect."
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by toper-centage on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @08:44AM
(#31568855)
Any negativity or anger seems to be in the article for purely comedic effect.
Re:Asking robots to design stained glass windows
by deelly on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @04:23AM
(#31567218)
If I use state of the art laptop, but funs are noisy, does it really matter how many thousand of thousand of thousand of hours spent to develop it?