Modern software is a service: it gets updated all the time, it's "hired to do a job" rather than perform a specific function. The latter is finite, controllable and could potentially be certified as an engineering product. The former relies on professional codes (and yes liability as well) to make sure that the service is acceptable.
All that is to say that the proper metaphor isn't licensing as for civil engineering or telco networks but akin to licensing for professional services, like medicine, accounting or law.
Which means different tiers of service, different expectations and yes much different compensation/service fees. But to get there we have to stop talking about 'engineering' as the correct framework. We're closer to lawyers or nurses...
The businesses we support are predominantly the professional services you list, so maybe a mental model of a professional services factory is where we're headed? You're certainly not wrong that software engineers need to be comfortable in those environments, but I suspect there's a bit of motivated reasoning among those who see our career becoming more like doctors, lawyers, and accountants, though I would love that to be the case. If anything, those professional jobs are looking more like engineering jobs over time as their own moats have been eroded. Aren't the software engineers coming along to make those professional careers look less special? I'm watching all the local dentist and optometrist offices get purchased up by chains instead of a new generation of small business owners. I'm not aware of another profession which has risen to those ranks, so I suspect their current place is merely a historical relic which is passing.
The service part seems more like greed than something I want (in many cases, certainty not all)
I love innovation as much as the next guy, there are constantly legitimately great advancements in software. That, however is not the same thing as a constant drive for change for changes sake. I want to pay a fair price for tools I can rely on today, not nebulous promises of future improvements that result in tools and processes being broken from time to time. It's not worth it. It's not a good trade-off. The idea that I can have something working perfectly fine and have it suddenly break the next day through no fault of my own is fucking abhorrent. I'm not here for it.
I'd doubt that a professional certification is needed for practitioners of software, but I could see merit in a certification body for software products. There are software products used in critical use cases, where the standard of practice for security, operations, or testing is insufficient for the desired use. As a client of such products, I might choose the "certified" version over the un-certified in a space where I don't believe feature velocity matters.
The problem with any of this would be making a compliance regime that didn't boil down to a boring ineffective process.
When it comes to software operating within known constraints, we're usually pretty good at delivering. The software in your car, for example, may be full of security holes if a human decides to attack it, but as far as working within the known environment, it is likely to work just fine and as expected. That is all we would expect of a professional engineer.
If you want to stop people from driving bulldozers into your buildings, you're going to have to look beyond the engineers. That is not their area of expertise.
They are liable for things like earthquakes and explosions, though, up to some limit:
https://www.fema.gov/emergency-managers/risk-management/eart...
Actually, they are.
Engineers are tasked with designing safe structures taking into account a bunch of failure modes, not only those that involve safety but also usability.
These failure modes are even covered in standards, and engineers who fail to design projects which are safe under these scenarios are held liable both civil and criminally.
Software, on the other had is expected to stand up to being exposed to nation state level threats that we know about, as well those in the future that we don't know about.
We can't get mad that Sony was hacked by North Korea in the same way that we wouldn't be mad at the engineers if the studio building burnt down after being bombed by the North Koreans.
We might, if military attacks were as commonplace, untraceable, and unpunished as online attacks.
I would offer that there is good reason why building security (e.g. police) is its own profession, not a traditional engineering discipline.
[1] https://www.cpr.org/show-segment/this-man-barely-escaped-kil...
If machine gun fire were a daily occurrence for residential houses, they would be. Every other common occurrence that occurs to residential houses, whether it's fire hazards, snow load on the roof, earthquake protection, etc. is part of the design consideration for residential houses.
The fact that software _predictably_ gets attacked when placed online is exactly what means that developers can't shrug their shoulders and pretend it's an unforeseen event.
How often do the people who pay for the software plan for that in their budgeting? Supposed I were to say this software has been pentested before release and it'll cost this much extra. How many people are paying for that? How many people will pay for it to be pentested each year for new vulnerabilities?
Most residential doors I've seen can't even stop someone with a credit card or metal shim, unless they have and actually use the deadbolt. The vast majority can be picked with ease if you have experience (and hackers typically do). You can also just check windows, since most people don't lock them.
If you don't have to leave the door intact, there's a billion ways to get in. You can ram through the door, since they're not terribly thick. You can drill out the locks. You can saw through the hinges and/or the bolts. If you really don't care, any number of guns can remove the locks or hinges.
An angle grinder will neatly handle any safe you're likely to find inside.
Firearms and tactics evolve over time and very few things can really be blamed on the engineer. The rules for PE are also based on evidence of due diligence on known problems rather than absolute liability, because nobody knows everything that could happen, and can't cover all possible failures. You should read up on how tanks are destroyed or stopped in inventive ways in guerilla warfare, such as in the ongoing Ukraine conflict (it's not just failure of maintenance) or in Vietnam war.
I also don't understand why you could selectively skip the part about novel chemicals.
Most of us are NOT engineers. Even less build software as engineers.
Er, no. The public wants software that “just works”. Everybody hates the new normal of eternal beta, or when their familiar and working software is changed to look or function differently, more often than not also removing existing conveniences and features.
To keep with the metaphor, I DO expect to plug an appliance in, though. Or that a room could be used for another purpose. Obviously changing from an office to a commercial kitchen is a major change but if that's what somebody wants to spend their money to do...
So I guess my thought is, "software engineering" and "engineering" are very broad. I actually think software challenges are not so unique. My experience has been that many people lack intuition about the software in question. Most people live in a building of some kind and if they asked for only Brawndo in the water pipes, it would be easy to convince them of how short sighted that is (or they wouldn't even ask). With software I feel like there's still some expectation of magic and zero friction just because it doesn't take a jackhammer to move a wall.
I also disagree that "we're doing the best we can." We're building monstrously complex systems because it pads our resumes, not because it actually solves real problems.
More than that, the reason most tech companies don't have a salaried plumber is because most tech companies don't rely on a plumber to try to increase the revenue of their core business model.
At the same time, there’s also no other industry that operates at a fraction of the speed of this one.
the public wants constant innovation
Seems less true to me than "VCs, entrepeneurs, middle management and MBAs want constant innovation", which is to say "capitalists want constant innovation". The constant churn is a sales-driven impulse to capture more of the market, and it's organizations throwing endless (and mostly pointless) change in order to move a few more units or renew a few more subscriptions. It's not the consumers who think software isn't finished, it's the people selling it.
Think about Office 97 and what you do today. Has anything added to MS Office since then mattered at a wide scale?
Be that as it may, Office 365/Teams are probably new since Office 97.
Arguably it wasn't a Microsoft innovation per se and was a response to Google Docs/Slack/etc. but internet/cloud/web-based collaborative editing integrated with group chat, video conferencing, and document sharing are probably new features since Office 97 that are somewhat useful, even if they don't work particularly well.
The idea that the markets can figure out how to build reliable and efficient infrastructure is contrary to evidence, theory or intuition. The actors are vastly asymmetric, information is hard to get by, risks hard to evaluate and judge, many infrastructures are natural monopolies, etc... And a large part of code in companies _is_ infrastructure.
In this type of context, people who would individually make shitty purchasing decisions generally support laws that support them in making better decisions (or in not having to make decisions). You do not want to evaluate whether saving 2$ on rent is worth the increased fire hazard of not having adequate fireproofing in the insulation.
You sure as hell wouldn't want the company to not be liable if they just installed the cheapest shit they could find and the building does burn down.
What? You mean like a company installing bad cladding that burns really easily, then refusing to take responsibility when a load of people's homes burn down and some are killed? Of course, that would never happen in the real world... ahem.
On what earth does "the public" wants innovations? The way it works is the tech industry has to work hard to sell innovations. Yes once the innovation is in, it creates a backward pressure for the rest of the industry.
If there was a transparent way to show pros and cons of these "innovations", the public might not be very keen. In certain areas (2D UI development) it's like the food industry where there is nothing left to innovate, they still keep making new, "better" (good looking but more toxic and addictive) food to sell.
They are always really enthusiastic and positive though.
Those of us who write it are trying as hard as we can to impose sensible and reusable structure on things, but the public wants constant innovation. Not the same "heat my house when I plus this in" demand they had 50 years ago that would have given us the stability to focus on standards, safety, and efficiency. We're doing the best we can.