News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by jerryjerryjerry on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:58AM (#31541339)
Some examples:

MySQL and PostgreSQL in C++: learning curve is long, hard to write good quality code for newbies;

Presto in Java: GC of java is a "nightmare", hard to have subtle memory management;

TiDB in Go: similar challenges to Presto/java of memory management;

TiKV in Rust: seems a good one but Rust itself is not as popular as other languages. Plus, some drama occurred with Rust core team last year...

Re: by siddontang on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:07PM (#31542407)
One of the founder of TiDB/TiKV here from PingCAP (https://pingcap.com)

I have been thinking about this problem with my peers when I started to build TiDB (https://github.com/pingcap/tidb) seven years ago. At that time, nearly all of us were familiar with Go language, so we decided to use Go to build the SQL layer of TiDB. Thanks to Go, we could develop TiDB very quickly and released the first MVP in half a year. I remembered clearly the sense when we ran TPC-C successfully, although the TPMC was just 1 at that time, this was a good start for us.

But Go had some problems, e.g. the GC was not good before, the fair scheduling might cause some latency problem, or data racing may happen sometimes. So when we decided to build a distributed storage (aha, TiKV (https://githbu.com/tikv/tikv), we wanted use another language to guarantee safety. I really admire our courage - we chose Rust which was just released 1.0 and missed lots of libraries at that time. Now it seems that this is an awesome choice, TiKV has been graduated from CNCF, and been used as building block not only for TiDB, but also for other distributed systems. Thanks Rust.

When TiDB started being used in many companies, we found that our customer not only ran lots of online transactions in TiDB, but also they wanted to ran some realtime analytic queries directly because the data has been in TiDB already. So we decided to build a HTAP database, to introduce a column storage beside TiKV, this is TiFlash (https://github.com/pingcap/tiflash). We build TiFlash based on Clickhouse, so of course, we use C++.

As you can see, to build only one integrated database - TiDB, we at least use three languages, every language has its own reason to be introduced. We can treat the distributed database as a service system, each service can be built with your favorite language and the services are linked by gRPC like TiDB does now. You may doubt that - “hey, guys, you are building a database, performance is very importance”. Yes, this is true, but we also build a complex distributed system, especially on the cloud. Scale-out, elastic, user experience must be important too. This is trade off for an engineer :-)

Re: by jerryjerryjerry on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:25PM (#31542531)
Thanks for sharing your great journey with these seemingly popular open source projects. You mentioned you chose Rust over Go when you started your storage project. Does that mean you would have chosen Rust if you start over a new database project now, especially for the cloud database service, or the language itself actually doesn't bother you at all?
Re: by siddontang on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:36PM (#31542596)
Maybe I will choose Go because this is my favorite language and I believe Go is going to get better and better
Re: by bruce-zhu on Saturday May 28, 2022 @07:12PM (#31544677)
Cloud can provider unlimited resources.

Maybe in future ,we will not need to make choice but choose the familiar one and totally relay the cloud’api and optimization.