I think it's worth noting that git did not replace tarballs and patches. Git replaced Bitkeeper. Bitkeeper, as far as I know, replaced tarballs and patches. And as far as I know, git did not start as a bunch of scripts for dealing with tarballs and patches. The design was inspired by his knowledge of and experience with Bitkeeper.
The workflow was indeed inspired by Bitkeeper, nothing is truly revolutionary, but Bitkeeper itself was not the status quo in a world dominated by CVS, SVN and Perforce.
On "tarballs and patches", I was referring to this famous quote from http://marc.info/?l=linux-kernel&m=111288700902396 ...
So I'm writing some scripts to try to track
things a whole lot faster. Initial indications
are that I should be able to do it almost as
quickly as I can just apply the patch, but
quite frankly, I'm at most half done, and if I
hit a snag maybe that's not true at all.
Anyway, the reason I can do it quickly is that
my scripts will _not_ be an SCM, they'll be a
very specific "log Linus' state" kind of thing.
That will make the linear patch merge a lot more
time-efficient, and thus possible.Bitkeeper was not the status quo, but I don't think that's important in the overall point. The original point was that git was inspired by previous software. The original software pointed at, cvs, was wrong, but I don't think the original point changes when we put the correct software, Bitkeeper, in its place in the sentence.
Yes, but I included a "not to diminish your point" right in the first sentence.
This was just a facts correction because I find the story of Git being fascinating.
Then I suppose my comment was a correction to the correction.
Re:John McCarthy Has Died
by thebigshane on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:05PM
(#3155106)
I think Alan Kay would disagree with you: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/432922/significant-new-in...
The basic idea here is not to bash the current state
of things but to try to understand something about the
progress of coming up with fundamental new ideas and
principles.
I claim that we need really new ideas in most areas of
computing, and I would like to know of any important and
powerful ones that have been done recently. If we can't
really find them, then we should ask "Why?" and "What
should we be doing?"
Which sounds to me like "The real fundamentals of computing happened a long time ago."Perhaps there will be a more significant revolution in our future but that doesn't contradict the above statement.
And I really think the world needs more people like Linus, as some wheels are worth reinventing.
In the words of Alan Kay: The computer revolution hasn't happened yet ... http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2950949730059754521 (listen to this talk because it's great).