Re:Perl is no more accurate than randomly-generated language
by j_baker on Monday October 24, 2011 @11:36PM
(#3152720)
I don't think anyone (the paper's authors included) would claim that this is objective proof that Perl is bad. I personally share your concerns. But wouldn't you at least agree that it's an interesting concept to try to test?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Perl is no more accurate than randomly-generated language
by celoyd on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @12:28AM
(#3152815)
Oh, I certainly don’t begrudge them running the experiment. I just wanted to put a check on the excessively anti-Perl interpretations that I thought were suggested by the title.
A more interesting test to me would be something like seeing how fast experts in a number of languages could extend or find a bug in code by other experts. I think there’s been a little research on this, but I don’t know enough to link to the best of it.
As I said, I dislike Perl’s syntax. But I think that, on the available evidence, it makes sense to see that an an opinion on the level of disliking cilantro, not on the level of disliking geocentric cosmology.