The little box challenge was significantly harder, primarily due to the ripple requirements on the DC side. This is not an issue in the same sense in the AC->DC case, because you don't have that problem there (you have other ripple considerations that might look similar, but are not (PFC and ripple on the output)). Usually you would require a lot of capacitance to solve the ripple issue for DC->AC and the winning team had a very interesting way of solving it without the use of very large capacitors.
What sort of power an electric drivetrain can handle for a burst of acceleration lasting a few seconds versus what that same drivetrain can handle as a continuous load are two very different things.
The same even applies with combustion powered cars too, if you look at the pickup truck market you'll see massive power numbers on every manufacturer's diesel pickups. If you look at their chassis-cab commercial trucks those same diesel engines are often derated by 30-50% compared to the pickups even while being equipped with larger cooling systems. That's because the commercial variants are rated to perform to spec all day every day where the pickup version just needs to put a grin on the owner's face when they floor it off the line and then occasionally tow a boat or something.
I'm not sure how much power it can handle continuously in a pure passive-cooling mode.
The LBC was misshapen because they had an odd requirement: Be single-phase. A three-phase inverter (or rectifier) naturally has low DC ripple and is both more compact and more efficient than a single-phase inverter at all power levels. All of the winning solutions had extra energy storage elements which added inefficiency and bulk which a three-phase inverter would not have needed.
With that in mind, the LBC was a little silly. A three-phase machine at the same power level would have been much smaller than any of the "winning" designs.
A high-efficiency ATX power supply has additional requirements that the LBC didn't need to meet: Isolation. This implies the use of a transformer to protect the low-voltage DC side from the AC side. They typically accomplish this by rectifing AC, using a transformer-isolated unidirectionally optimized DC/DC supply to 12V, and then provide a handful of lower-power DC/DC converters to derive the other voltage levels used by ATX. A modern unisolated DC->AC machine is effectively symmetric in its power flow, and also functions as an AC->DC machine.
By using a higher frequency, the transformer can be much smaller and more efficient. If they were doing mains 60hz AC the transformer would be substantially larger.
I forget if they also step the supply side DC voltage up too…
They do, but they don't have to. The front-end rectifier boosts the voltage up to 400-450 VDC. This way, most of the components can be optimized for a single world-wide compatible machine that is capable of rectifying 230VAC.
In principle, you could squeeze out a bit of efficiency (or cost) by producing a North American market machine that was optimized for 120V and a separate machine optimized for 208/230V. In practice, supply chain simplification reduces overall per-unit costs, so just about everything is designed as a single machine for world-wide markets. Only the plugs change. For ATX, only the cord shipping in the box changes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-emitting_diode#Blue_LED
I wonder what new engineering knowledge has emerged about gallium nitride that allowed it to become such a recent force in power supply electronics.
I didn't know that gallium nitride is transparent.
It's been known for some time that GaN has a superior electron mobility number (which, effectively means you can get a better/smaller/lower impedance/faster switching device depending on which tradeoff you want). Problem is, getting reasonably good process control has been challenging. It appears some folks in the industry have been overcoming that challenge, therefore we're seeing the results of that.
Little Box Challenge went the other direction: instead of taking AC and producing DC power, it was an inverter that took DC power and produced AC output. It had to output 2kW and be smaller than 655 cubic centimeters (cc's). The winning Red Electrical Devil's team got 3x more dense than this[2]! 240 cc's! While inverting 2kW of juice. Second place was 340ccs.
I don't know whether we'd argue this DC->AC is harder/easier than an ATX supply (AC->DC) (probably not?) but this was quite an impressive competition, almost a decade ago, that resulted in probably some of the most power-dense, highest-efficiency power conversions that humanity has ever gotten up to. For compare, this 250W unit is 212cc's. 8x less power conversion, 88% the size.
The Little Box Challenge designs were published, so there's a ton of great reading. Alas, Google frakking let the damned site bitrot off the net?! Sooo, head to archive.org[3] to read the team's writeups. From the winning CET Red Electric Devils writeup:
> GaN transistors have many very interesting electrical characteristics (low Rds_on, low Qgate and Cds, ultra low Qrr); these create technological advantages over current MOSFET and IGBT devices (small size and low production costs). Unfortunately, they also have serious drawbacks due to their very fast switching characteristics: they are challenging to drive and require sensitive electromagnetic noise management. Another pitfall is the high voltage drop due to the reverse current when the GaN is turned off. The solution selected to overcome these difficulties is to control all the GaN transistors using soft switching for the entire operation range.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8070215 (271 points, 8 years ago, 138 comments)
[2] https://ai.googleblog.com/2016/02/and-winner-of-1-million-li...
[3] http://web.archive.org/web/20171006105655/https://littleboxc...