News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by cbozeman on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:03PM (#31523868)
I often hear this and let me just pose this question...

Damn near everyone in America, at least, has access to YouTube or other streaming services. I learned how to program in R from The Teaching Company Plus' (now Wondrium)'s "Learning Statistics: Concepts and Applications in R". 24 lectures. 12 hours of content. Resources available for download. It was the springboard that allowed me to seek out deeper resources and expand my knowledge. Total price, $10.81 for a one month subscription.

You can probably find a lot of equally good free courses at other websites.

My point being this. The information is out there for people willing to seek it out. I came up poor. Really poor. Like, we're having mayonnaise sandwiches tonight for dinner poor. And if you're wondering what's in a mayonnaise sandwich, it's in the name. Mayonnaise. Bread. Period.

Now maybe we need to cultivate a sense of curiosity in our students, so even the ones who end up as warehouse workers at an Amazon can one day aspire to something greater, but at some point, people have to take some responsibility for how their own lives are turning out.

It's really easy to point the finger to society, to the government, to the person next door to you, but at the end of the day, most people have the tools (smartphones, cheap laptops), and they absolutely have the time. But the drive is something that no government program or no private initiative can give them - that you have to pull out of your gut yourself. And if you can't do that, you're doomed to a life of mediocrity.

Choose your hard.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by arinlen on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:29PM (#31524069)
> Damn near everyone in America, at least, has access to YouTube or other streaming services. I learned how to program in R (...)

Enough with this pseudo-moralistic perpetuation of abuse, specially the tone-deaf ones based on survivorship bias.

Just because someone is not able to win the lottery that does not mean they have no right to earn a living wage that allows them a honest living.

Aren't we supposed to live in a civilized society? Why are you unwittingly normalizing exploitation and the widespread abuse that bars the majority of families from having a decent life? If not for the parents who can't be self-taught engineers, why not for their children? Are those also expected to endure hardship?

Just pay people a fair wage. Is it that hard?

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by cbozeman on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:52PM (#31524242)
> Just pay people a fair wage. Is it that hard?

Yes. Because we have no idea how to define 'fair'. I hear 'fair wage' over and over but no one can ever explain to me what makes the wage 'fair' other than, "I have a job and I should be able to live on that single job!"

Okay... why? Where is it written that you should be able to live on a single job?

As soon as you can come up with an argument that's not emotive, and is instead quantitative, I'll listen.

Right now, all I hear from people parroting this is that, "It's not right!"

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by arinlen on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:20PM (#31531373)
> Yes. Because we have no idea how to define 'fair'.

Well, we do. I mean, we have a pretty solid idea of what represents the absolute bare minimum. For starters, minimum wage should be a living wage. It should be enough all on its own to meet living expenses, including paying for a modest apartment, without breaking any effort rate limit.

Is this too hard?

Are we supposed to pretend that some people simply do not have a right to have a decent life?

> . I hear 'fair wage' over and over but no one can ever explain to me what makes the wage 'fair' other than, "I have a job and I should be able to live on that single job!"

Why exactly do you have a hard time understanding this?

Look at yourself. Look at the living expenses you have, specially the basic necessities. You pay for the roof over your head, for the food on your plate, for the clothes on your back. Do you have a hard time quantifying that?

This is even simpler than that. Landlords and banks already use the concept of effort rate. They already know that if someone's effort rate goes beyond 40% then they are at a significant risk of financial distress. Is it too hard to start from there and determine what's a living wage in any region?

Or is there zero lack of interest, and a desire to pull the ladder out of your own feet to screw everyone less fortunate than you?

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by greazy on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:52AM (#31526400)
> Okay... why? Where is it written that you should be able to live on a single job?

> As soon as you can come up with an argument that's not emotive, and is instead quantitative, I'll listen.

I have a feeling that you will not accept any argument based on general morality as you would describe it as 'emotive'.

I think first that humans should not spend the majority of their lives working and sleeping. In other words: surviving. Especially when there are more than enough resources available to achieve this ( in your country).

Second, exploiting other humans (as above) is absolutely wrong.

These two arguments are not emotionally driven.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by FieryTransition on Thursday May 26, 2022 @08:32PM (#31524881)
So the solution is to chase whatever the market dictates as "well paying", despite being against your interests, maybe drop whatever responsibilities you might have or just, like you say, live in mediocrity, if your socio economic situation forked your chances from the beginning, and your inherent abilities just don't cut it? Do you walk by the less fortunate, and think, they just didn't work hard enough and "kind of" are at fault for their own situation? Because that's a very typical American way of thinking, one that people adapt in America to cope with the poverty around them. I've seen it, from aquinteces who became big, moved to America, and slowly changed their view of people to cope with their suffering and their own fortune, partly due to a really badly made social system. And unfortunately, there are plenty of places like this besides America.
Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by yunohn on Thursday May 26, 2022 @08:06PM (#31524741)
So… your point is that “anyone can become a developer that pays good money”? And this is a solution for systemic poverty and classism?

Who do you think keeps society and your life functioning while you sit in front of a computer and code?

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by cbozeman on Thursday May 26, 2022 @09:17PM (#31525139)
My point is that anyone can learn what they want to do on YouTube.

I served with an Electronics Technician in the Navy who started watching YouTube videos on commercial HVAC and now he does that as a living, servicing mostly restaurants in the Fort Worth-Dallas Metroplex, and not just making a "living", but last year his one-man operation made $300,000.

Not too shabby for just watching YouTube and going to get the necessary certifications.

Do you want to make the best pizza on the planet? There are YouTube videos out there from chefs all over the world, freely giving away their recipes. All you gotta do is pick up the ingredients and get started.

If someone wants it bad enough, they'll go get it, they won't wait for it to be handed to them.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by over_bridge on Thursday May 26, 2022 @09:30PM (#31525210)
And what if the thing you want to do pays a wage below livable? Or no wage at all.

Not everyone wants to be a software developer or something that makes a lot of money and it's a damn bleak view of the world where the grand diversity of the human race is squashed into a profit-chasing monoculture of workers. Just throw away your dreams and install air conditioning. It's the will of the market.

We've gone from the Renaissance ideals of being well rounded and interesting people to being the best single purpose cog in the machine, devoid of any values except making money. What a depressing attitude when we could just focus on treating people fairly and with respect whatever their choices.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by blindmute on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:27AM (#31528765)
"We" haven't gone anywhere. If you have to work now, you would have had to work just as much in the Renaissance. Those ideals were by and for independently wealthy aristocrats. The working class has always and will always work. If you're willing to have the quality of life that a Renaissance working class man had, 15/hr is plenty.
Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by yunohn on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:48AM (#31530277)
“We’ve always subjugated and mistreated the working class” is not the win that you think it is.
Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by blindmute on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:49PM (#31532526)
The working class has never had it better than they have it right now, except for a brief period of a few years in the mid 20th century. You wouldn't know it though, from all the complaining. Sure, society "should" keep improving, but in the meantime there's plenty of ways for someone to improve their situation, and none of those ways involve complaining about rich people.
Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by yunohn on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:20PM (#31532936)
Do you mean they get to enjoy the fruits of modern life, and hence shouldn’t complain? Again, that’s not a valid argument.

Let’s use some data, for example wealth distribution (1) - the lower classes have stayed lower income, and the middle class is rapidly transferring wealth to the upper classes. How is this sustainable?

(1) https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/01/09/trends-...

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by blindmute on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:12PM (#31537006)
It's not an issue of data. Wealth inequality by itself doesn't do anything bad, if the bottom can still afford what they need. It's a matter of having a realistic mindset and sense of self determination. A poor person today in the west has it drastically better than any poor person ever in history; they have a better quality of life as a poor person, and they have mind-bogglingly high levels of income mobility, in a historical sense. No other time in history could someone so easily go from poor to middle class.

So when people spend so much mental energy complaining about how things aren't "fair", okay, sure, but you could instead just improve your situation. There will always be poor people, but an individual will not always be poor. We are not yet anywhere close to a situation where the highest expected value of an individual's time is to complain (instigating revolt).

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by yunohn on Monday May 30, 2022 @05:06AM (#31556966)
Look, this is really a pathetic line of argument. If you’re selling self-help books, sure go ahead.

This discussion is about minimum wage, wealth gaps, and relative compensation of CEOs. You do realise that? If you think everything is perfect, feel free to ignore such threads. The status quo exists and doesn’t need your support.

Saying that working class people can just work harder and get higher paying jobs, doesn’t solve anyone’s problem. In fact, it only furthers the problem that only some jobs get a living wage, and even fewer jobs get a good wage.

I have no idea why you think it’s okay to tell poor people to “just improve their situation”, and contribute both their/our tax money towards enriching the wealthy.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by blindmute on Monday May 30, 2022 @09:21AM (#31558678)
Sorry, but no, I will comment my views as I please, whether they support the status quo or not. As this is a public forum, you'd do well to find a way to cope with differing views.

I was poor. I improved my situation. I didn't spend much time complaining about rich people on the internet, because that would have detracted from the time I taught myself marketable skills for 8 hours a day, every day, for 7 months, while delivering pizzas and living in a shithole with 3 other people. You're right though, complaining would have been much easier, but somehow I don't think I'd still be making a quarter mil if I had taken that route.

"Pathetic" to recommend people work hard and fix their life? That sentiment itself is what's pathetic. The world doesn't owe you shit.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by yunohn on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:53AM (#31560301)
I don’t believe the working class is sitting on HN and complaining - it’s mainly people like us who spend exorbitant taxes on a system that doesn’t actually help anyone. It’s not clear to me if you understand this nuance.

Anyways, your repeated “I got mine, fuck you” mentality is very boring and toxic - https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/michaeltomasky/201....

Good luck, happy that you solved poverty! I’ll stop engaging as this thread will lead nowhere.

Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by blindmute on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:33AM (#31569275)
The working class is absolutely sitting on Twitter and complaining. It's sad that you view advice to improve yourself as a toxic "fuck you". Is your locus of control so far externalized?
Re:Amazon investors nuke ethics overhaul and say yes to $212... by yunohn on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:21AM (#31527909)
Okay, but if “everyone” goes out and gets a high paying job, who is leftover to do the jobs that keep us all functioning? Should we just mistreat them because they didn’t watch enough YouTube and “upskill” themselves?