Re:Perl is no more accurate than randomly-generated language
by wccrawford on Monday October 24, 2011 @08:24PM
(#3152210)
Suddenly I'd like to know how other languages fare. I have a feeling they might not be much better.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Perl is no more accurate than randomly-generated language
by jerf on Monday October 24, 2011 @08:57PM
(#3152294)
Of the current suite of top 20 languages at TIOBE (which for all its faults is as good as any other top-20 list), the ones that I know of that have heavy pedagogical backgrounds (that is, designed to teach students, not merely used to teach students because they were already popular) would be Python, Visual Basic, and Pascal, with Python's background probably being the most recent with its ABC predecessor, which some Googling suggests dates to the late 1980s, at which point the other two were already heading down the "industrial strength" path. Those would be the most interesting to test.
(If you're in a hurry to mention Scheme, that's #27. And on the list of "pedagogical languages" it would still be beaten by Logo at #23, which, frankly, is a sign we probably shouldn't trust the list at all below about #20....)
Re:Perl is no more accurate than randomly-generated language
by edsrzf on Monday October 24, 2011 @08:40PM
(#3152241)
You may be in luck. The paper says:
"Given this interesting first result, we plan to test a number of additional languages using the same procedures."
Hopefully they'll use larger sample sizes too. This one involved 18 people across 3 groups.