Re:People in homes with handguns more likely to be killed, m...
by quantumduck on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:23PM
(#31520269)
I mean correlation doesn't mean causation. Perhaps the very reason the bought a handgun is because they thought they had some threat or were involved in activity that would increase their likely hood of getting killed.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:People in homes with handguns more likely to be killed, m...
by projektfu on Thursday May 26, 2022 @01:24PM
(#31521019)
This study looks at the broader question of people who started living with handguns in the house, from a baseline of no handgun, so many of those victims are not people purchasing weapons themselves.
The absolute numbers are low (12 killings / 100,000 pop as opposed to 8 / 100,000 in the control group).
I don't think the article claimed causation but you can't determine causation from this type of study either. There's a possibility of the data being random, as well as causality going the other way, but it is hard to temporalize getting killed causing someone to start having a handgun in the home before that point. There's also a possible third unknown and causal association that is responsible for both the killing and the prior presence of the gun. That is a definite place to do research.
Re:People in homes with handguns more likely to be killed, m...
by Mattasher on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:09PM
(#31521592)
If we start with those numbers and a null hyp that both the control and the "experimental" group have a mean of 10, then the chance that of finding 4 or more extra killings than in the "experimental" group is about 21%. So even assuming no p-hacking, your p-value is meaningless.
R-code:
sum( (rpois(10000,10) - rpois(10000,10) ) > 3)