I think people are misreading my comment as saying "I have so many things I want to do, and there isn't enough time to do them, and GTD doesn't help."
This is not my problem. My problem is:
"I have a lot of items on my Someday/Maybe list, over 90% of which will not be done, and that's OK. Reviewing this list every week (as GTD tells me to) to decide if I should move any to the 'Active' list is a huge burden"
If you are stuck and can't choose in a reasonable time, pick at random, and work on it: avoid multitasking (if it "maybe/someday" task, then you can afford it).
If 1000 hours over 4 years is too much for your purposes, pick a different frequency -- having the habit should help either way. If there is no amount of time you are willing to reserve for your list than call it "Never" (that is fine -- as one data hoarder to another).
- Someday (I'm 90% sure I am going to do this, but I'm not actively working on it right now). This gets looked at during my weekly review.
- Maybe (I might do this at some point, but I'm 90% sure I won't do it in the next month). This gets looked at during my monthly review.
For the "Maybe", to be frank, I just stopped updating it. Instead I now have a sort of bucket list: Things I'd really like to do before I die. Even if I can't do all, I should be able to do quite a bit of these. It's basically a "higher priority" Maybe list. The idea is when a random thought pops up into my head ("Write a blog post on X"), I ask myself "Does this belong in the bucket list?" If not: "Wouldn't my time be better spent on the bucket list?" If yes, I just discard the thought. Sure, it'll pop into my head often, but why bother adding it to my "Maybe" list if I can't be bothered to review that huge list?