Re:Paul Graham Publicly Releases Nodejitsu From Hacker News ...
by pg on Monday October 24, 2011 @02:11PM
(#3150793)
It's such a drag that HN comments now become news stories. Now when I write something I have to think about how it will sound in print. Plus it decreases the information content of HN to have articles that are essentially dupes of old comment threads.
I didn't even realize Heroku was the company they were claiming I'd banned them to help. I assumed they meant another smaller company we funded that's focused specifically on Node.
Re:Paul Graham Publicly Releases Nodejitsu From Hacker News ...
by msumpter on Monday October 24, 2011 @02:25PM
(#3150868)
Working at a company that maintains several forums; I've found that anything we say publicly can and will be construed to suit whatever agenda they aggrieved party wants to play into. There will always be claims of bias in moderation but all you can do is try to apply the same yard stick to everyone. And still hold feet to the fire when they break the community guidelines.
Re:Paul Graham Publicly Releases Nodejitsu From Hacker News ...
by eggbrain on Monday October 24, 2011 @02:33PM
(#3150901)
Paul Graham represents a brand bigger than himself. When you stop caring what you say to who, it has implications to all those companies that belong to that bigger brand, along with the brand itself.
Re:Paul Graham Publicly Releases Nodejitsu From Hacker News ...
by ilaksh on Monday October 24, 2011 @02:46PM
(#3150952)
What is the other company you funded that's focused specifically on Node? Was it no.de, Nodester, nodesocket, bejes.us? If you don't mind, what makes that solution worth funding?
Re:Paul Graham Publicly Releases Nodejitsu From Hacker News ...
by jesusabdullah on Monday October 24, 2011 @02:34PM
(#3150904)
Disclaimer: I work at Nodejitsu, but my words are my own.
> It's such a drag that HN comments now become news stories.
Oh, c'mon. This isn't like some quiet "just my buddies" forum. HN, whether you like it or not, is a place where "movers and shakers" communicate what's happening to them or what they think, so of course it's going to become news. It's like complaining that people actually pay attention to your tweets.
> I didn't even realize Heroku was the company they were claiming I'd banned them to help.
People may have insinuated that YC/HN was/is engaging in shill-esque activities (it's an easy thing to do), but I don't think anybody representing Nodejitsu made this claim, nor do I think they would if pressed.
Re:Paul Graham Publicly Releases Nodejitsu From Hacker News ...
by wccrawford on Monday October 24, 2011 @02:34PM
(#3150905)
"if you’re not sure, don’t."
This is a guideline that ethical people already follow. At least, until they've asked permission.
People who claim to be ethical will do things until they're told not to, claiming that if they weren't forbidden, it's not unethical.
The thing is, ethics doesn't care if you were forbidden or not. It's not about rules or laws. It's about doing what's right, and not doing what's not right.
Accidents happen, and I'm not saying they don't... But there's a huge difference between doing things that you know are harmful to another party (even though they haven't said so) and doing things that you don't realize are harmful.
I didn't even realize Heroku was the company they were claiming I'd banned them to help. I assumed they meant another smaller company we funded that's focused specifically on Node.
> It's such a drag that HN comments now become news stories.
Oh, c'mon. This isn't like some quiet "just my buddies" forum. HN, whether you like it or not, is a place where "movers and shakers" communicate what's happening to them or what they think, so of course it's going to become news. It's like complaining that people actually pay attention to your tweets.
> I didn't even realize Heroku was the company they were claiming I'd banned them to help.
People may have insinuated that YC/HN was/is engaging in shill-esque activities (it's an easy thing to do), but I don't think anybody representing Nodejitsu made this claim, nor do I think they would if pressed.
Can we stop talking about this now?
This is a guideline that ethical people already follow. At least, until they've asked permission.
People who claim to be ethical will do things until they're told not to, claiming that if they weren't forbidden, it's not unethical.
The thing is, ethics doesn't care if you were forbidden or not. It's not about rules or laws. It's about doing what's right, and not doing what's not right.
Accidents happen, and I'm not saying they don't... But there's a huge difference between doing things that you know are harmful to another party (even though they haven't said so) and doing things that you don't realize are harmful.