Exactly. The reason I pay for proton mail is not so that proton mail doesn’t know I’m a customer. It’s because proton mail doesn't read my emails. Gmail/Google does. That’s what privacy is important to me as an email user.
Sometimes it feels like people scream security === anonymity === privacy and really don’t understand what they’re even yelling about.
Yet if use android Proton is stick to google push service till today, even when IMAP itself actually has push function since IMAP4.
Robust privacy (you choose what to disclose to whom) often presents as anonymity to third parties
And Proton is marketing themselves as anonymity friendly: https://proton.me/news/climate-activist-arrest
Re:Updated Proton, Unified Protection
by stjohnswarts on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @01:43PM
(#31507912)
Anonymity can be a big part of privacy, which is fairly obvious and for some people it's inside that privacy circle as a necessary component.
I guess I don't know what sort of abuse they experience, but for spam I'd think $10 / month would be more than sufficient.
What if that $10/mo is going to result in a charge back from the stolen credit card? That, on top of spam and whatever other abuse is going on with that account.
OK, then only accept crypto for anonymous accounts.
Honestly, cryptocurrencies (I hate that these have hijacked "crypto" for their silly garbage, to me crypto will always be cryptography. Old man yells at cloud I guess..) just invite abuse. As a service provider I'd never offer cryptocurrency as payment if that service could be abused in one way or another. Just my experience, to each their own.
I don't like it either (to put it mildly) but Mullvad allows cash to be send to them, no questions asked. You can even pay for various months that way.
Proton also supports cash for renewals/upgrades, but they went out of their way to remove the cryptocurrency option and the cash option during signup...
And it would be easy for Proton, because they already accept cryptocurrency for subsequent payments after account creation, but not for the first payment during account creation (catch 22)
In the end it's their choice to continue collecting personal data, even after Swiss authorities compelled them to disclose personal data to French authorities: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ProtonMail#Compliance_with_Swi...
I can see why they do what they do, it probably prevents a lot of spam accounts and abusive use type accounts from being created. But privacy doesn't mean anonymous. If you want anonymous I don't think Proton is for you.